Judge orders Moyo to be reinstated as CEO of Old Mutual

Judge orders Moyo to be reinstated as CEO of Old Mutual
Published: 30 July 2019 (857 Views)
The South Gauteng High Court has ordered Old Mutual and respondents to temporarily reinstate Peter Moyo as CEO, who was fired in June and to put a halt on any decision to replace him. It also ordered the insurer and respondents to pay costs.

Judge Adams ruled that his suspension and dismissal were unlawful.

Moyo, long standing and respected executive, took the 174 year Old Mutual and its current Chairperson Trevor Manuel, to court, for unfair dismissal. It is a legal battle that could have far reaching implications for corporate South Africa.

Moyo was suspended as CEO in May after the insurance group said there had been a material breakdown of trust and confidence. This related to a company Moyo co-founded, in 2002, NMT Capital, in which Old Mutual was a significant investor. The company asserts that Moyo put the interests of NMT before those of Old Mutual, something he was contractually not allowed to do.

"For Corporate South Africa it could mean that even the slightest conflict of interest is taken a lot more seriously than it currently is," says Morris Mthombeni, a corporate governance expert and lecturer at GIBS. Mthombeni says it appears Moyo has taken quite a drastic measure in filing such serious charges against Old Mutual and its board. Moyo claims the board of Old Mutual did not follow due process in releasing him and has asked the courts to reinstate him as CEO. He is also requesting that the chairman and directors be declared "delinquent directors."

"Unfortunately the board and Mr Moyo have disagreed materially on how the conflict of interest has been managed," counters Old Mutual.

Old Mutual bought 20 percent of NMT Capital for R200 million, in 2002, as part of its transformation agenda. This initial investment was split between ordinary shares, preference shares and private equity.

As a preference shareholder, Old Mutual is entitled to be paid dividends first, but Moyo insists this is a right they often waived.

"In practice and since 2010, the redemption of Old Mutual preference dividends has been deferred or "rolled over" by agreement for a continuous period of almost a decade to date," said Moyo in his application to the South Gauteng High Court.

Instead, Moyo believes his alleged victimisation is a result of him raising concerns about what he says is a conflict of interest for Old Mutual chairman and former minister of finance Trevor Manuel. This, he claims, relates to the split of Old Mutual UK from the South African business, where Rothschild, another company  Manuel is chairman of, were the lead advisers for a small fortune in advisory fees.

This, as well as an undisclosed payment of Manuel's legal fees, amount to what Moyo terms a "triple conflict."

Old Mutual rejects Moyo's claims without reservation and intends to rebut them in court.

The escalation of this high profile disagreement to the courts raises an interesting set of questions around corporate governance and practitioners are sure to watch this closely.

Mthombeni says although this is not a watershed moment in corporate  governance in South Africa, "it will show if we give lip service to conflicts of interest."

- www.cnbcafrica.com

 0

You May Like These Videos

Comments

There are no comments.

Latest stories

Mnangagwa denies Majonga 'love rivalry' allegations

by Staff reporter | 21 August 2019 | 9 Views

Mphoko, ZACC strike deal

by ZimLive | 21 August 2019 | 7 Views

Mnangagwa dragged into Mphoko, Zacc fight

by Staff reporter | 21 August 2019 | 8 Views

Chamisa's MDC fails to pay salaries

by newzimbabwe | 21 August 2019 | 4 Views

Mnangagwa: Reformist, corruption buster chimera

by Paidamoyo Muzulu | 21 August 2019 | 8 Views

'Mnangagwa threatened to kill Majonga over High school lover'

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 August 2019 | 29 Views

Chamisa will never dance to Mnangagwa's tune

by Staff Reporter | 21 August 2019 | 32 Views

'Phelekezela Mphoko guarded by CIOs'

by Staff Reporter | 21 August 2019 | 30 Views

Latest on MDC Masvingo mass demonstrations

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 August 2019 | 26 Views

ZANU PF youth leader attacks Jonathan Moyo

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 August 2019 | 21 Views

Biti takes on Mnangagwa

by Daniel Itai | 21 August 2019 | 108 Views

Police ban MDC Masvingo mass demonstration

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 August 2019 | 88 Views

WATCH: Latest on Phelekezela Mphoko

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 August 2019 | 98 Views

Chamisa's supporters jailed over dangerous weapons

by Staff reporter | 21 August 2019 | 80 Views

Mnangagwa's govt defends police position on MDC Chamisa's demos

by Staff reporter | 21 August 2019 | 60 Views

Mthuli Ncube to issue new coins, notes

by Bloomberg | 21 August 2019 | 78 Views

Chief Ndiweni fights conviction & sentence

by Staff reporter | 21 August 2019 | 53 Views

Mnangagwa's govt slams EU's 'intrusive attitude'

by Staff reporter | 21 August 2019 | 80 Views

US regime change in Zimbabwe getting brazenly silly

by Isdore Guvamombe | 21 August 2019 | 57 Views

Bulawayo bomb scare: Army called in

by Staff reporter | 21 August 2019 | 54 Views

Poison fearing Mphoko now a wanted man

by Staff reporter | 21 August 2019 | 69 Views

Police in 5-day cybercrime training

by Staff reporter | 21 August 2019 | 58 Views

War veterans recommend anti-sanctions holiday

by Staff reporter | 21 August 2019 | 56 Views

Zimbabwe is a country of laws

by Tino Chinyoka | 21 August 2019 | 55 Views

Mnangaga appoints five new judges

by Staff reporter | 21 August 2019 | 43 Views

FC Platinum shift base to Bulawayo

by Staff reporter | 21 August 2019 | 54 Views

Mtukudzi's daughter engages Steve Dyer

by Staff reporter | 21 August 2019 | 66 Views

Caps Utd elevates Darling Dodo

by Staff reporter | 21 August 2019 | 46 Views

Stanbic Bank recruits more student interns

by Staff reporter | 21 August 2019 | 41 Views

Zimbabwe democratic space has shrunk

by Learnmore Zuze | 21 August 2019 | 43 Views

Teachers threaten chalks down

by Staff reporter | 21 August 2019 | 34 Views

13-year-old girl married off for $80 in Zimbabwe

by Staff reporter | 21 August 2019 | 38 Views

Fuel situation in Zimbabwe improves

by Mandla Ndlovu | 21 August 2019 | 48 Views

Zec pushes for transparency

by Staff reporter | 21 August 2019 | 37 Views

Chamisa party's ex-workers eye MDC's govt grant

by Staff reporter | 21 August 2019 | 31 Views