Controversy rocks Econet meeting

Controversy rocks Econet meeting
Published: 11 February 2017 (174 Views)

THERE was drama at Econet Wireless Zimbabwe's extraordinary general meeting (EGM) when state-run National Social Security Authority (Nssa), together with other shareholders and proxies, took the mobile phone operator to task over possible conflict of interest regarding a capital-raising exercise.

Econet is currently seeking shareholder approval for a capital raise of US$130 million by way of a rights offer of ordinary shares and linked debentures in order to facilitate the servicing of its foreign debt.

Sources who attended the company's EGM told the Zimbabwe Independent that while shareholders voted for the rights offer on February 3, several issues pertaining the capital raise were raised by concerned shareholders.

In its initial circular that unnerved local investors, Econet had announced that proceeds of the rights offer must be paid by each participating shareholder into the debt service account held by Econet with the African Export and Import Bank outside Zimbabwe and for the proceeds to be applied by the company to repay its secured loan obligations.

Nssa is one of the top 20 shareholders in Econet with 1% of issued share capital.

According to a Nssa insider who spoke to this newspaper, the pension fund raised fundamental problems of conflict of interest on the part of the underwriter, Econet Wireless Global (EWG), which currently has 30% shareholding in Econet Wireless Zimbabwe (EWZ) Holdings Ltd.

EWG is registered in Mauritius and has operations and business interests, in more than 17 countries around the world, including Zimbabwe. EWZ operates only in Zimbabwe, and has no businesses, operations or investments outside Zimbabwe. Investment in the shares of EWZ are with respect only to the businesses, and activities of EWZ.

"As Nssa we raised two points: firstly we questioned if there was any other option other than the US$130 million capital raise that the company could pursue. We felt that the underwriter could have settled the obligations, then once this was done shareholders would now deal directly with the underwriter," an insider said.

"Another issue was that we felt that the underwriter shouldn't have participated in the capital raise."

Another market watcher also concurred, questioning the participation of EWG.

"The underwriter is a related party — whereas the circular sought to portray EGL as an unrelated party.

The company chairman Godfrey Gomwe sought to cite examples where Nssa itself has underwritten some issues in trying to justify this position. (Tawanda) Nyambirai (the lead financial advisor to the rights offer) tried to explain this using some ZSE rules — but it's clear EGL as a 30% shareholder is a related conflicted party," an analyst who attended the meeting queried.

"Imara Nominees also complained about the overnight and improperly communicated change over the rights of the local shareholders which is material and would affect how they voted, especially given that they had submitted proxies. Gomwe responded that the change will hopefully make shareholders vote positively, which is an advantage.

"Stanbic Nominees also raised concerns about why the guarantor EGL did not step in and pay the debt given that it's a guarantor being paid 6%. There was no meaningful response to this question.

Then Hardy Pemhiwa, representing EGL, also spoke about the fact that the change requiring local shareholders to pay locally was rushed and they also need changes to the resolution. He proposed an amendment to resolution number four on debentures so that the debentures can be listed on a foreign exchange for trading.

The convening of the EGM against board directive has resulted in Zimbabwe Stock Exchange chief executive Alban Chirume being suspended. Chirume was last week dodgy on whether or not the meeting would be held despite several issues that were raised by the board questioning the capital raise.

Independent columnist Brett Chulu, in his article today, says if Econet had insisted on just raising funds through a rights offer, it would have encountered a serious problem — it does not have enough unissued shares to offer at a bargain of 5 US cents a share.

At 5 cents a share, Econet would have raised only 5% of the US$130 million required to meet its financial obligations.

"For Econet Wireless Global, the 30,2% majority shareholder in Econet, using its influence at board level to have the rights offer take the underwriting option (back stop commitment), would have been a no-brainer. It is very likely that the fear of losing control drove Econet Global to insert itself as the underwriter to pick up any shares not taken up by other shareholders," Chulu writes. "It explains why the shares were massively discounted to enable the underwriter to buy these without having to break the bank.

It also sheds light into why a clause was inserted to the effect that EWG, the underwriter, could elect to either offer minorities the shares it mops or not … It can calibrate the shareholding level it desires. EWG could not afford to put its fate in the hands of either an independent underwriter or a process of re-allocating mopped up shares it could not control."

- the independent

 0

You May Like These Videos

Comments

| Comment With Facebook Submit

There are no comments.

Business Big Reads

Zimbabwe inflation hits two-year high but still negative

by Staff reporter | 16 February 2017 | 95 Views

RBZ caps bank charges

by Staff reporter | 16 February 2017 | 147 Views

Banking sector profits jump to $181 million

by Staff reporter | 16 February 2017 | 104 Views

WorldRemit, Zimpost launch instant money transfers to Zimbabwe

by Agencies | 15 February 2017 | 131 Views

South African banks manipulated the US dollar - Rand rate

by Staff reporter | 15 February 2017 | 185 Views

Unilever Zimbabwe to slash salaries by 50%

by Staff reporter | 15 February 2017 | 127 Views

Strive Masiyiwa company acquires SA's Neotel

by Staff reporter | 15 February 2017 | 157 Views

fastjet Zimbabwe collects $2.7m airport taxes

by Staff reporter | 15 February 2017 | 101 Views

Air Zimbabwe to get new planes

by Staff reporter | 14 February 2017 | 145 Views

Strong dollar threatens Zimbabwe exports

by Staff reporter | 14 February 2017 | 103 Views

Zesa sues Ingwebu Breweries over debt

by Staff reporter | 13 February 2017 | 124 Views

Ingwebu Breweries to be privatised

by Staff reporter | 13 February 2017 | 111 Views

Controversy rocks Econet meeting

by Staff reporter | 11 February 2017 | 174 Views

Zimbabwe 'inflation' imported, says RBZ

by Staff reporter | 10 February 2017 | 185 Views

Fastjet suspends Victoria Falls-Johannesburg route

by Staff reporter | 10 February 2017 | 193 Views

Chirume faces ZSE chop, sent on forced leave

by Staff reporter | 09 February 2017 | 193 Views

Cash crunch 'haunts' Mangudya

by Staff reporter | 09 February 2017 | 219 Views

Zimbabwe mobile operators lose over $26 million in 10 months

by Staff reporter | 08 February 2017 | 289 Views

Tsvangirai promise to re-open Ziscosteel

by Staff reporter | 08 February 2017 | 162 Views

ZSE sent CEO on leave over Econet saga

by Staff reporter | 07 February 2017 | 169 Views

StanChart cancels visa services for Zimbabweans

by Staff reporter | 07 February 2017 | 206 Views

ZSE plots to crack whip on defiant Econet

by Staff reporter | 06 February 2017 | 134 Views

Econet shareholders approve rights issue

by Staff reporter | 06 February 2017 | 156 Views

Econet EGM going ahead despite

by Staff reporter | 02 February 2017 | 335 Views

Storm over Econet $130 million rights offer

by Staff reporter | 02 February 2017 | 184 Views

Econet loses 400 000 subscribers

by Staff reporter | 02 February 2017 | 255 Views

Air Zimbabwe struggling to pay IATA debt

by Staff reporter | 02 February 2017 | 197 Views

DStv parent eyes Zimbabwe mobile firms

by Staff reporter | 01 February 2017 | 242 Views

Zimplats revenue up 41%

by Staff reporter | 01 February 2017 | 211 Views

Vacancy - Junior Forex Dealer

by GroCapital Financial Services | 31 January 2017 | 225 Views

Zimbabwe has over-valued US$ exchange rate

by Staff reporter | 31 January 2017 | 178 Views

Zimbabwe should put in place a comprehensive economic reform plan

by Staff reporter | 31 January 2017 | 166 Views

Boost for Alaska – Karoi power project

by Alice Dube | 30 January 2017 | 198 Views

Matabeleland mines scoop top awards

by Business Reporter | 30 January 2017 | 345 Views

Zimbabwe has only $300 million in circulation

by Staff reporter | 29 January 2017 | 210 Views

Econet shareholders lose $100 million in 10 days

by Staff reporter | 29 January 2017 | 201 Views

Econet summoned over contentious issues

by Staff reporter | 27 January 2017 | 208 Views

Zimbabwe industry to push for adoption of Rand

by Staff reporter | 27 January 2017 | 278 Views