Leopards in the crossfire

Leopards in the crossfire
Published: 23 March 2017 (2359 Views)
If cats do have nine lives, leopards are on their last. Especially the big, strong males of the species as the DEA seems set on reintroducing leopard trophy hunting quotas.

The DEA issued a zero quota for 2016 and 2017 - effectively enforcing a ban on leopard trophy hunting in South Africa. The decision followed a report by the Scientific Authority that found leopard population estimates unreliable and consequently, hunting practices unsustainable. Accordingly, a precautionary hunting quota in 2018 was only to be implemented following a number of interventions including the development of the norms and standards for the management and monitoring of leopard hunting.

These norms, which apply if quotas are reinstated, were recently released by the DEA and opened for comment.

Contentiously, the norms state that only adult males, seven years or older, may be hunted. While meant to protect females, and viably reproductive leopards, the norms quote a study which concludes that off take of older males has little impact on populations. According to the norms, if this age limit is adhered to the number of animals available to hunt exceeds that proposed for a sustainable population (10 -16% compared to the recommended 3.6%), essentially negating the very purpose of the norms and standards.

Pieter Kat is just one big cat expert disputing this study, "the '7 year rule' was based on a computer model generated on very limited information in Tanzania. Off take of leopards in South Africa should not be guided by such non-reproducible studies in eastern Africa." He goes on to say, "If those requirements cannot be proven, the entire proposed age limitation of hunted leopards becomes irrelevant."

There is also debate concerning if hunters can reliably age and sex leopards. The DEA says professional hunters will need to, "pass a once-off leopard hunting examination." However the website provides unlimited practice exams and one study quoted in the norms even says, "Respondents performed poorly at aging male leopards, with less than 50% of photographs classified correctly. Hunters recorded the lowest scores."

In the event that a younger male or female is hunted then that particular Leopard Hunting Zone (LHZ) will not be issued a quota the following season and an export permit won't be issued. However Helen Turnbull of the Cape Leopard Trust says that, "there is an illustrated lack of compliance amongst the hunting fraternity, as well as a lack of capacity at management level for adequate and realistic policing of the new protocols that are proposed in order to ensure only males over the recommended age of seven years are targeted."

The norms propose the SANBI-established LHZs with the allocation of one permit per property or zone per year, stating that a, "hunting permit allocated to one LHZ cannot be used in another LHZ."  But, "apart from the geographic limitation of one quota per LHZ, there needs to be clear reference as to how the quota will be allocated to an applicant," says Kelly Marnewick of the EWT. She has also raised concern that there will not be, "enough time for DEA and SANBI to evaluate and analyse data and adaptively manage the quota for the following year."

Turnbull also questions the work done by SANBI in the creation of the LHZ. She says, "the population estimates in the Western and Eastern Cape have not been adequately researched. We, as the Cape Leopard Trust, do not agree with the proposed hunting quota of 4 leopards for the Western Cape Province, and are in support of the rejection of this quota by the provincial issuing authority, Cape Nature."

Tharia Unwin, Chief Executive Officer of the PHASA, says that without hunting, landowners have no incentives for habitat conservation, "The legal off take of leopard is not the problem. On the contrary, without any legal off take, there is no incentive for landowners to tolerate predators." But Bool Smuts of the Landmark Leopard Predator Project believes that, "this document is a deliberate attempt, despite evidence to the contrary, to appease the hunting industry."

Although the purpose of the norms is to manage the hunting of the leopard in order to reduce the impact of this practice on the species, trophy hunting seems to be going ahead despite the fact that it may still present a high risk to the survival of leopards in South Africa.


- conservationaction.co.za

 0

You May Like These Videos

Comments

There are no comments.

Latest stories

Morgan Tsvangirai and the making of a national hero

by Tafi Mhaka | 16 February 2018 | 289 Views

Tsvangirai the legacy

by Daniel Itai | 16 February 2018 | 254 Views

Zuma's demise

by Daniel Itai | 16 February 2018 | 297 Views

Tsvangirai supporters organise red Saturday in honour of him

by Stephen Jakes | 16 February 2018 | 524 Views

Tsvangirai burial set for Buhera

by Staff reporter | 16 February 2018 | 322 Views

Tsvangirai Funeral Update: Khupe deployed to SA

by Nelson Chamisa | 16 February 2018 | 366 Views

Khupe apologises

by Dr Thokozani Khupe | 16 February 2018 | 932 Views

Mnangagwa, army commanders tensions grow

by Staff reporter | 16 February 2018 | 389 Views

Tsvangirai's death, political phonies and crocodile tears

by Staff reporter | 16 February 2018 | 191 Views

The hypocrisy of Zanu-PF is utterly suffocating

by Brezhnev Malaba | 16 February 2018 | 154 Views

Zimbabwe to mortgage minerals for capital

by Staff reporter | 16 February 2018 | 119 Views

Tsvangirai's death fuels MDC-T turmoil

by Staff reporter | 16 February 2018 | 155 Views

Gukurahundi victims want their voices heard

by Nqobani Ndlovu in Maphisa | 16 February 2018 | 111 Views

Mudede sued over dual citizenship

by Staff reporter | 16 February 2018 | 209 Views

Mnangagwa, Mugabe fallout - Mugabe security further reduced

by Staff reporter | 16 February 2018 | 533 Views

MDC UK & Ireland Youth Statement on the death of Morgan Tsvangirai

by Vusumuzi B Ncube | 16 February 2018 | 196 Views

Momentary celebrity cannot erase Zimbabweans' common sense

by Brian T Kagoro | 16 February 2018 | 184 Views

How to avoid flawed elections in Zimbabwe

by Ibbo Mandaza & Tony Reeler | 16 February 2018 | 187 Views

Chivayo braces for bruising wrangle

by Business Weekly | 16 February 2018 | 211 Views

Obert Mpofu cleared, he is not corrupt

by Business Weekly | 16 February 2018 | 310 Views

Mnangagwa urged to repeal laws that hinder free polls

by Staff reporter | 16 February 2018 | 150 Views

Cheating wife agony

by Staff reporter | 16 February 2018 | 337 Views

Man dumped for preying on maids

by Staff reporter | 16 February 2018 | 236 Views

Sangoma 'steals' wife

by Staff reporter | 16 February 2018 | 174 Views

Highlanders in no rush to spend

by Staff reporter | 16 February 2018 | 126 Views

Bees sting woman to death

by Staff reporter | 16 February 2018 | 140 Views

Busted while servicing pal's hubby

by Staff reporter | 16 February 2018 | 297 Views

Tsvangirai was courage personified

by Conway Nkumbuzo Tutani | 16 February 2018 | 122 Views

Woman runs amok in house fight

by Staff reporter | 16 February 2018 | 130 Views

Student savagely attacked by lover's wife, hired hit men

by Staff reporter | 16 February 2018 | 113 Views

Jilted cop 'impounds' ex-wife's panties

by Staff reporter | 16 February 2018 | 102 Views

Drama as hubby busts wife, lover

by Staff reporter | 16 February 2018 | 187 Views

Desperate fuel thieves arrested

by Staff reporter | 16 February 2018 | 94 Views

Dembare, CAPS match moved

by Staff reporter | 16 February 2018 | 141 Views

Zanu-PF MP sued over child upkeep

by Staff reporter | 16 February 2018 | 91 Views

Blow for Zacc

by Staff reporter | 16 February 2018 | 114 Views