MDC-T hypocrisy on Makarau exposed

MDC-T hypocrisy on Makarau exposed
Published: 12 September 2017 (200 Views)
Attempts by the MDC-T to discredit Zimbabwe Electoral Commission chairperson Justice Rita Makarau for holding three key offices, including being a Supreme Court judge and secretary for Judicial Services Commission, have exposed the opposition party's hypocrisy as it endorsed the arrangement during the constitution making process when it was in the inclusive Government.

Constitutional law expert Professor Lovemore Madhuku yesterday urged the MDC-T to thoroughly read the Constitution.

This was after MDC-T spokesperson, Mr Obert Gutu, yesterday sought to cast aspersion on Justice Makarau, saying she should relinquish some of her positions.

Prof Madhuku rapped the MDC-T for hypocrisy when it was the opposition party that endorsed the arrangement through a Constitutional provision stipulating that one could not be ZEC chairperson when he or she is not a Supreme Court or High Court judge.

Section 238 (2) of the Constitution provides as follows: "The chairperson of the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission must be a judge, or former judge or a person qualified for appointment as a judge."

Prof Madhuku said the MDC-T were playing double standards by criticising an arrangement that they pushed for during the constitution making process.

"They included in the Constitution a provision which stipulated that you cannot be chairperson of ZEC when you are not a judge," he said. "They were involved in putting up that provision which said you have to be a judge for one to be chairperson of ZEC.

"As long as that provision is there, it is difficult to understand what they are saying. They cannot have it both ways. That is double standards."
Mr Gutu released a press statement denouncing Justice Makarau.

"The ideal situation is for Rita Makarau to only have one job at a time, especially taking into account the fact that being the ZEC chairperson is an extremely demanding job that should be a full time vocation, as is the case in most Sadc countries," he said.

"We have absolutely no shortage of suitably qualified and experienced people to perform the other jobs that Rita Makarau is presently holding onto. The present state of affairs does not bode well for both efficiency and good corporate governance."

Asked why the MDC-T was raising the issue now, Mr Gutu claimed that they were merely placing emphasis on a point they had made before.

The MDC-T has lost to Zanu-PF in all elections it has participated since its formation in 1999.

Political analyst, Mr Goodwine Mureriwa, said what the MDC-T was saying was an indication that it had panicked and had realised that they would lose the elections.

He said Justice Makarau had been holding the three positions since the time of the inclusive Government which the MDC-T was part of before the 2013 harmonised elections where it dismally lost to Zanu-PF.

Mr Mureriwa said it was in fact MDC-T leader, Mr Morgan Tsvangirai, who announced the appointment of Justice Makarau after he concurred with other principals in the inclusive Government for her appointment.

Other principals were President Mugabe and the then Deputy Prime Minister Professor Arthur Mutambara.

"Mr Tsvangirai actually said he was happy with Justice Makarau as she was professional," said Mr Mureriwa. "They have now realised that time is fast running out as they are trying to put up an alliance and go to the people at a time when Zanu-PF is already on the ground."

Another analyst, Professor Isheunesu Mupepereki said the MDC-T realised that they were staring election defeat.

"They are now raising issues that are not relevant, to get attention," he said. "It is also another way of trying to get possible funding from their Western donors."

Justice Makarau had not yet responded to questions sent to her through the Zec's public relations department and the office of the chief elections officer, Mrs Constance Chigwamba, at the time of going to print.

- chronicle

Tags: MDC-T, Makarau, Vote,
 0

You May Like These Videos

Comments

There are no comments.

Latest stories

Sleeping Mugabe now a huge liability

by Staff reporter | 24 September 2017 | 173 Views

BREAKING: Armed cops storm church, arrests Mawarire while preaching

by Staff reporter | 24 September 2017 | 199 Views

Bulawayo rejects bond notes

by Staff reporter | 24 September 2017 | 229 Views

Bosso, Dembare booted out of Chibuku Cup

by Staff reporter | 24 September 2017 | 106 Views

What to do now that Tsvangirai is sick?

by Barnabas Thondhlana | 24 September 2017 | 127 Views

WATCH: RBZ trying to calm panicked Zimbabweans

by Ndou Paul | 24 September 2017 | 96 Views

Zimbabwe now back to 2008 doom

by Staff reporter | 24 September 2017 | 103 Views

Zimbabwe prisoners deprived of ARVs

by Staff reporter | 24 September 2017 | 60 Views

Mujuru's death will remain a mystry

by Staf reporter | 24 September 2017 | 70 Views

Mugabe set to appoint a deputy chief justice

by Staff reporter | 24 September 2017 | 60 Views

Koreans to perform Jah Prayzah's 'Mdhara Achauya'

by Staff reporter | 24 September 2017 | 82 Views

Zimbabwe parliament reduced to hall of comedy

by Staff reporter | 24 September 2017 | 60 Views

MDC Alliance continues to face resistance from Matabeleland

by Staff reporter | 24 September 2017 | 29 Views

Might Warriors beaten by Banyana Banyana

by Staff reporter | 24 September 2017 | 64 Views

Tsvangirai get this honest opinion and analysis to protect your legacy

by Tinashe Eric Muzamhindo | 24 September 2017 | 62 Views

NRZ $400 million deal 'dead in the water'

by Staff reporter | 23 September 2017 | 117 Views

Issue IDs for free: Chombo

by Staff reporter | 23 September 2017 | 121 Views

ZESA Holdings training intake

by zesa | 23 September 2017 | 149 Views

Kingship and Nationalism will not solve Matabeleland problems

by Mbonisi Gumbo | 23 September 2017 | 90 Views

Zimbabwe's own Kenneth Kaunda

by Staff reporter | 23 September 2017 | 101 Views

Death row inmates graduate

by Staff reporter | 23 September 2017 | 111 Views

$153 million for RG Mugabe Airport upgrade

by Staff reporter | 23 September 2017 | 75 Views

Nhari-Badza rebellion was always coming

by Staff reporter | 23 September 2017 | 111 Views

Harare - Beitbridge road dualisation starts

by Staff reporter | 23 September 2017 | 97 Views

PDP Coalition status, setting the record straight

by Jacob Mafume, PDP Spokesperson | 23 September 2017 | 85 Views

Mphoko consoles Msika family

by Staff reporter | 23 September 2017 | 71 Views

Violent Grace surprises South African police

by Israel Dube | 23 September 2017 | 219 Views

Is Zimbabwe opposition ready to remove Mugabe regime?

by Sakhile Sibanda | 23 September 2017 | 103 Views

Tsvangirai's greed has turned into madness and now it threatens us all

by Wilbert Mukori | 23 September 2017 | 162 Views

Wishing Tsvangirai a speedy recovery, Cdes

by CZ | 23 September 2017 | 89 Views

Malawi President praises Mugabe

by Staff reporter | 23 September 2017 | 81 Views

Raffle ticket books vanish at police station

by Staff reporter | 23 September 2017 | 78 Views

Mugabe's government owes MDC-T $3 million

by Staff reporter | 23 September 2017 | 75 Views

Ailing Tsvangirai to stay longer in S. Africa

by Staff reporter | 23 September 2017 | 85 Views

Minister assures civil servants on bonuses

by Staff reporter | 23 September 2017 | 77 Views

Man mistakes hawker for wife's lover

by Staff reporter | 23 September 2017 | 96 Views

Mujuru, Biti, Dabengwa form another coalition

by Staff reporter | 23 September 2017 | 83 Views