Former English football referee says Dembare goal was offside

Former English football referee says Dembare goal was offside
Published: 16 May 2017 (348 Views)
THE International Football Association Board, the organisation in charge of writing and amending regulations that govern world football, yesterday cast light on the controversy sparked by a big call made by assistant referee Thomas Kusosa which led to the abandonment of the big match between Highlanders and Dynamos.

A fierce debate continued to dominate domestic football yesterday as the row over the controversial goal scored by Dynamos, which led to the abandonment of the big match, raged on.

Bosso fans charged that DeMbare's Cameroonian import Christian Ntoupa Epoupa's strike in the 42nd minute should not have been allowed to stand because the forward was in an offside position by the time he picked up possession.

But Dynamos fans have been arguing that their striker, who appeared offside when defender Elisha Muroiwa hit the ball goalwards, was played onside when the ball came off Highlanders' defender Peter Muduwa.

It also emerged yesterday that the graphic which was published in many mainstream newspapers yesterday does not answer the question related to the events at Barbourfields on Sunday and most of those regulations were for the 2004 season and have long been updated.

While both camps are clear on the provisions of Law 11, which deals with offside, the difference — it appears — is found in the interpretation of the law:

Was the ball, which came off Muduwa, a result of an attempt by the defender to block Muroiwa's effort and, if that was the case, what does the law say?

Did the ball just deflect off the Bosso defender, without an attempt by him to play it, and if that is the case, what does the law say?

The IFAB Technical Director David Elleray yesterday cast light on the issue and said, according to the latest amendments to Law 11:

If a defending player "deflects" a pass from an opponent which immediately goes to a player who was in an offside position then that player can be penalised for offside.

If a defending player deliberately plays the ball and it goes to a player who was in an offside position then that player is not penalised for offside. It does not matter if the ball does not go where the defender intended, if he played the ball deliberately then the Law does not exist to "save" his poor play.

In simple terms a "deflection" is when the player does not move towards the ball or make an attempt to play it (in effect he is "hit" by the ball).

The local refereeing experts, themselves, failed to agree yesterday with one saying, as far as he could see, the assistant referee should have penalised the Cameroonian for being in an offside position.

"The wording is very tricky, and that is where you can either get it wrong or right, and as far as I am concerned, the incident was just an attempted clearance, or blockage, of the ball by the opposition defender and when the ball went to the striker he didn't make him onside because if the same ball had gone to the 'keeper from that defender, there is no way that the 'keeper could have been penalised for handling a back pass because it wasn't,'' said one expert.

But the other expert had a different view. "The law asks if there was an attempt to block the shot, and if there was and a deflection resulted from that, then that defending player cannot be protected by his carelessness and that way the opposition forward, who was offside, becomes onside because he is receiving the ball from his opponent,'' he said.

"I can ask you another question, if that ball had gone into the nets, whose goal would you have given to — the Dynamos player who had hit it at the beginning or the last player who touched it, in this case the Bosso player?

"If you can answer that, and having seen that the ball in question actually changed direction in a very big way, then it should give you an idea that this was a play that can be punished and the assistant referee who made that call that the striker wasn't offside made the right call.

"In any way, whatever the case, surely, you can't tell me that was the basis of a match being abandoned because we have seen even worse incidents, where the calls, in my opinion, were wrong in the English Premiership this weekend, but the matches went the distance."

- the herald

Tags: Offside, Dembare, Bosso,
 0

You May Like These Videos

Comments

There are no comments.

Latest stories

Bosso change colour

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2017 | 68 Views

Caps United stun Alger

by Thobekile Zhou | 24 May 2017 | 112 Views

Mnangagwa's command agriculture: A ploy for the 2018 elections

by The Solutions Tower Staff | 24 May 2017 | 64 Views

I want my Dynamos job back, Silva says

by Alice Charamba | 24 May 2017 | 91 Views

Khama blow for Warriors?

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2017 | 123 Views

Mutasa targets boo boys

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2017 | 91 Views

Muroiwa absence explained

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2017 | 76 Views

Prophet arrested over mbanje

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2017 | 111 Views

Mystery haunts man

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2017 | 106 Views

Former Bulawayo City man takes over at Harare City

by Thobekile Zhou | 24 May 2017 | 78 Views

Lumumba withdraws ConCourt application

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2017 | 94 Views

War vet appears in court over Zanu-PF violence at Davies Hall

by Stephen Jakes | 24 May 2017 | 82 Views

Clear priorities set for Zimbabwe

by Agencies | 24 May 2017 | 74 Views

MDC-T official house burnt

by Thobekile Zhou | 24 May 2017 | 126 Views

NMBZ performing well, AGM told

by Mike Hamilton | 24 May 2017 | 66 Views

First test tube baby born in Zimbabwe

by Chengetai Chinembiri | 24 May 2017 | 125 Views

Zimbabwe National Army dispels recruitment rumours

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2017 | 77 Views

Pastor Chamisa, a dictator in the making

by Tafara Shumba | 24 May 2017 | 119 Views

Sekurutau to headline Africa Day Concert

by Jones Mbiri, Gem Nation News | 24 May 2017 | 64 Views

Swift action needed to bail ZESA

by John Sigauke | 24 May 2017 | 57 Views

The creation of Zimbabwe's Frankenstein

by Tendai Mazenge | 24 May 2017 | 85 Views

Mugabe has been looking a bit frail of late – and it may be deliberate

by Carien du Plessis, News24 | 24 May 2017 | 193 Views

'Tsvangirai not fully recovered'

by Online | 24 May 2017 | 230 Views

Suspended Gershem Pasi resigns from Zimra

by Ndou Paul | 24 May 2017 | 164 Views

10 people feared dead in Zimbabwe mine shaft collapse

by Simbarashe Sithole | 24 May 2017 | 181 Views

What is wrong with Mugabe's Vice Presidents?

by PDP Communications | 24 May 2017 | 93 Views

New school to open in Matabeleland South

by Thobekile Zhou | 24 May 2017 | 77 Views

Racism and prejudice, my personal encounters

by Whitlaw Mugwiji | 24 May 2017 | 70 Views

Highlanders FC disciplinary judgement update

by Thobekile Zhou | 24 May 2017 | 113 Views

Potato shortages hit Zimbabwe

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2017 | 99 Views

Censorship board tenure increased as Bona is drafted in

by Alice Charamba | 24 May 2017 | 128 Views

Drunk cop in deep trouble, identified

by Zhou Thobekile | 24 May 2017 | 161 Views

Charumbira declare total war on Kasukuwere

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2017 | 207 Views

'Mugabe's govt sabotaging Matabeleland education,' says Zimta

by Thobekile Zhou | 24 May 2017 | 85 Views

Hidden agenda behind Zanu-PF violence, says Mphoko

by Thobekile Zhou | 24 May 2017 | 124 Views

Police urged to be ruthless with kombi drivers

by Thobekile Zhou | 24 May 2017 | 106 Views