Peter Moyo vs. Old Mutual: 7 key factors as they head to court

Peter Moyo vs. Old Mutual: 7 key factors as they head to court
Published: 16 July 2019 (95 Views)
Ex-Old Mutual CEO Peter Moyo heads to court on Tuesday to challenge his dismissal by the financial giant.

The legal wrangle centres around the blue-chip company's dismissal of its former chief executive, with Moyo mounting a challenge against Old Mutual over his dismissal in June over what the company called "a breakdown in trust and confidence". Old Mutual had initially suspended him on May 23.

In the urgent two-part application, Moyo has also asked the court to grant him an interdict preventing Old Mutual from appointing his replacement and declare his suspension and dismissal unlawful and unconstitutional.

Part B of the application, intended to be set in motion within 60 days of the outcome of Part A, would see him lodge a damages claim. He also wants the 17-member board to be declared "delinquent directors".

Below are some of the key factors that form part of his case:

1. NMT Capital dividend payment and 'conflict of interest'

NMT is a company co-funded by Moyo in 2002 and Old Mutual Life Assurance Company, a subsidiary of Old Mutual, is an investor in NMT Capital. Moyo has a 25% stake in NMT. Moyo declared the relationship when Moyo was appointed CEO of Old Mutual Emerging Markets in 2017.

However, Old Mutual has taken issue with the 2018 payment of a total of R115m ordinary dividend in March and July 2018 by NMT. The payment was done while preferential share dividends to Old Mutual were in arrears, according to the company.

Old Mutual alleges that as Moyo was paid a share of R30.6m, as part of the payout, this in breach of Old Mutual's rights as preference shareholder.

In his affidavit, Moyo says Old Mutual was eventually paid the preferential dividend in October 2018.

2. Why the NMT dividend matters

The ordinary dividend of R115m was declared without evidence of proper solvency and liquidity analysis, according to Old Mutual. The company had a R157m debt with Industrial Development Corporation (IDC).

Old Mutual states that the IDC debt wasn't disclosed in a board pack for an NMT board meeting on 4 July 2018, and that the company was in a unsatisfactory financial position.

It says the dividend was declared "without evidence that a proper solvency and liquidity analysis was conducted...which materially affected its solvency analysis." During this period, Old Mutual preference share dividends were in arrears.

3. Termination of employment contract

The 56-year-old is aggrieved that his suspension and ultimate dismissal was without a hearing.

He says at his level and status of employment, the mere suggestion that he was found guilty of conflict of interest "was instantly damaging to my reputation and good name in the business word and society in general".

On the other hand, Old Mutual says there is no legal or factual basis that his termination of employment was in breach of contract, noting that Moyo has elected not to pursue the matter under the provisions of the Labour Relations Act.

4. A fair chance - or not

Moyo accused Old Mutual chair Trevor Manuel of spearheading his dismissal, but the the company maintains that his suspension was due to a breakdown in the relationship between himself and the board, and that Moyo is portraying himself as "the victim of adverse publicity".

It says Moyo is welcome to bring a claim against the company, but contends that the board tried unsuccessfully to engage him to "secure an agreed separation" that could be announced publicly, with his consent.

5. Whistle-blowing

Moyo states that he objected to the payment of legal fees by Old Mutual in a litigation case involving Manuel. Old Mutual is rejecting the claim, say he "supported the legal expenses and gave the required instructions".

In its response, the company rejects the claim as "disingenuous attempt to deflect attention from the matters that led to the termination of his employment".

6. Manuel's conflict of interest in Old Mutual Managed Separation

Manuel's involvement with Rothschild, the company that advised Old Mutual on the Managed Separation process, is listed by Moyo as one of the issues he flagged as conflict interest on the part of the chair.

Old Mutual rejects claims of potential conflict, saying the relationship between Rothschild existed before he became board chairman and was disclosed.

"The suggestion that this issue had anything to do with the decision to terminate the Applicant's employment is quite simply ludicrous."

7. Victimisation

Chief among Moyo's grievances are victimisation claims which are mainly attributed to Manuel. He says his relationship with the chair deteriorated after he raised the issue of his potential conflict of interest in the Managed Separation.

He said from that point, Manuel's attitude towards him deteriorated, "followed by other relative smaller incidents of pettiness in the ensuing months".

Moyo further states that Manuel "grossly mishandled" the issue of breach of protocol in the NMT saga, which came to his attention towards the end of April 2019.

- fin24


You May Like These Videos


There are no comments.

Latest stories

Europe sends a strong message to Mnangagwa

by Mandla Ndlovu | 20 August 2019 | 83 Views

Jonathan Moyo, Kirsty Coventry mourn Mnangagwa's 'love-rival'

by Mandla Ndlovu | 20 August 2019 | 76 Views

Our 'scoop' obsessed jurnos, first things first

by Tondorindo Murisa. | 20 August 2019 | 48 Views

A Letter to Zimbabwe National Army Officers

by Poverty-Stricken Zimbabwean | 20 August 2019 | 71 Views

Chamisa's hired soldiers caught with their pants down

by Dr Masimba Mavaza | 20 August 2019 | 76 Views

European Union shocks Mnangagwa's government

by Mandla Ndlovu | 20 August 2019 | 66 Views

Rebecca Malope retires

by Mandla Ndlovu | 20 August 2019 | 110 Views

The Crocodile in Crisis

by The Times | 20 August 2019 | 136 Views

'Zimbabwe to issue cash notes soon'

by Bloomberg | 20 August 2019 | 184 Views

Zimbabwe youths rally behind Chief Ndiweni

by Mandla Ndlovu | 20 August 2019 | 139 Views

Zimbabwean woman forced to give birth standing up in South Africa

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2019 | 146 Views

Open letter to Jacob Mudenda: What was your role during Gukurahundi?

by Nicholas Ncube | 20 August 2019 | 102 Views

Moral authority is a pre-requisite for Good Governance

by Big Monday with Tinashe Eric Muzamhindo writes: | 20 August 2019 | 78 Views

Zimdiaspora in final push

by Thabo Makuyana | 20 August 2019 | 93 Views

WATCH: Soldiers in Gweru march on behalf of Chamisa's MDC

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2019 | 177 Views

August 16 exposes the MDC's insincerity

by Nobleman Runyanga | 20 August 2019 | 80 Views

Mnangagwa 'love rival' dies

by Staff Reporter | 20 August 2019 | 136 Views

State effects a de facto ban on civilian politics

by Luke Tamborinyoka | 20 August 2019 | 87 Views

Chitembwe signs Harare City deal

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2019 | 80 Views

Zanu-PF congratulates Mnangagwa

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2019 | 82 Views

Govt hires 19 doctors

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2019 | 85 Views

Duo in trouble for assaulting ex-mayor

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2019 | 76 Views

Kambarami and Chigora found not guilty

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2019 | 85 Views

BREAKING: Bomb scare in Bulawayo

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2019 | 87 Views

Match fixing scandal rocks Zifa Southern Region

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2019 | 73 Views

Chunga not qualified to coach TelOne side

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2019 | 86 Views

Zanu-PF hails Sadc

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2019 | 70 Views

Teen gangster pleads guilty

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2019 | 65 Views

No pay, no invigilation: Zimsec told

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2019 | 61 Views

Chamisa raises ante against Mnangagwa

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2019 | 69 Views

Police ban MDC Gweru demonstrations

by Mandla Ndlovu | 20 August 2019 | 52 Views

Zanu-PF vows resistance against MDC 'regime change' plot

by newzimbabwe | 20 August 2019 | 48 Views

MDC's campaign for Chief Ndiweni release worrisome

by Editorial - Newsday | 20 August 2019 | 65 Views

Rural teachers chicken out

by Staff reporter | 20 August 2019 | 39 Views

Protests a form of feedback

by Zanda Shumba | 20 August 2019 | 39 Views