NRZ $400 million deal 'dead in the water'

NRZ $400 million deal 'dead in the water'
Published: 23 September 2017 (166 Views)
THE US$400 million deal between the National Railways of Zimbabwe (NRZ) and DIDG/Transnet is effectively dead and buried and Government might soon re-tender the project, a Cabinet minister has revealed.

This comes as some stakeholders tried to salvage the deal last week.

Though the local partners of Transnet, the Diaspora Investment and Development Group (DIDG) had secured letters of commitment from South African banks to fund the transaction, it emerged that Government was mainly sceptical of the financial health of Transnet, including its recent controversy in neighbouring Botswana, where it reportedly did a shoddy job.

The Minister of Transport and Infrastructure Development, Dr Joram Gumbo, told The Sunday Mail Business that Government has concluded that the proposed deal is not good for the country.

"The NRZ deal went to Cabinet and was rejected, you must have gotten that information.

"The deal didn't go through. When it was assessed, it was found out that it was not good for the country,” he said.

Pressed to explain why the deal was rejected, Dr Gumbo noted that "Cabinet deliberations are not publicly discussed”.

However, it has since been established that Cabinet unanimously concluded that awarding the tender to DIDG/Transnet was a risky undertaking for the country.

Sources believe that the South African parastatal wanted to use the deal as leverage to borrow money from China.

"That is where the problem is. It (Transnet) does not have the money and some locals are the ones who looked for money on behalf of the company.

"Remember that this deal started during the time when Dr Obert Mpofu was still the Minister of Transport and Infrastructure Development. Even during the Dr Mpofu era, DIDG/ Transnet said ‘if you give us the tender, we will get money from China' and most ministers said it would be ridiculous to allow a company to borrow money from somewhere then come and try to sell us that money again,” said a source close to the deal who requested anonymity as the issue is still sensitive.

"It was therefore suggested that we can just borrow money from China on our own to avoid interest on interest (compound). So Cabinet was not happy with the deal.”

But it is Transnet's controversial deal with Botswana last year that has been the most damaging.

Botswana Railways (BR) ordered 30 coaches from the South African firm, and most of those that were eventually delivered had technical hitches.

There was also controversy on the way the deal was structured.

While Transnet claims that it managed to clinch the Botswana deal through a competitive bidding process, which essentially opens up the process to many participants, it has since emerged that it, in fact, was chosen from a selective tender process that was facilitated by an unnamed businessperson.

All this has since cast doubt on the ability of the South African state-owned enterprise to meaningfully contribute to the local project.

"Transnet did not do other jobs well in the past. In Botswana, they are said to have messed on a wagons deal, where they claimed to have supplied new wagons and on commissioning, they could not work and it was found out that they were old,” added the source.

Transnet could not be reached for comment by the time of going to print.

Dr Gumbo, however, indicated that going forward, Government "will look for new investors” to revive NRZ.

But there are fears that the abortive NRZ deal will naturally dampen investor interest in the asset.

It is even made worse by the failure of the Ziscosteel deal, where a deal with Indian firm Essar was stillborn.

Dr Gumbo disagrees: "Those who say the deal will have a bearing on investors can say so but when you have been given a tender, the devil is in the detail. When you inspect issues to do with repayment terms, interest rates, how the money will come, and the conditions precedent and so on, you end up abandoning the winner of a tender.

"So when one is awarded a tender, it does not mean the project is all yours, there would be lots of issues that have to be checked. We need to establish what exactly is being bought.”

Although there are indications that the deal is doomed, discussions are still continuing between the parties involved, with the hope that it can still be salvaged.

Government is currently on a mission to restructure State-owned enterprises as they are viewed as a key enabler to economic growth.

NRZ, Air Zimbabwe, Ziscosteel and the Civil Aviation Authority of Zimbabwe (CAAZ) are some of the parastatals that Government is keen to revive.

Already, Cabinet has approved a plan to assume legacy debts close to US$1 billion that the selected parastatals have chalked up.

NRZ has a legacy debt of US$348 million.

A new law — the Public Entities Corporate Governance Bill — also seeks to facilitate the efficient management and administration of public entities.

If the NRZ deal had sailed through, it is believed that the rail operator would have been set on a path of sustainable recovery.

- sundaymail

Tags: NRZ, Deal, Deal,
 0

You May Like These Videos

Comments

There are no comments.

Latest stories

Mujuru is a reject and she must not be allowed near national coffers

by Tinashe Eric Muzamhindo | 19 October 2017 | 31 Views

Veld fire destroys hectares of land in Guruve

by Simbarashe Sithole | 19 October 2017 | 31 Views

Traditional leafy vegetables into your garden

by Praxedis Dube, Rico Ihle, Wim Heijman and Paul Struik | 19 October 2017 | 30 Views

Climate change induced droughts fuel spread of HIV in Africa

by Andrew Mambondiyani | 19 October 2017 | 26 Views

PICTURES: PPC, Lafarge in Zimbabwe advert war

by Social media | 19 October 2017 | 34 Views

WATCH: Chinotimba is not satisfied with the cost of fuel in Zimbabwe

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 35 Views

WATCH: Chinotimba triggers mini chaos in parly

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 30 Views

Madrid recolonise Catalonia

by BBC | 19 October 2017 | 28 Views

Africa must finance own civil registration, says Mudede

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 48 Views

Biti takes on Zec head on

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 84 Views

Chinamasa saved by the bell

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 72 Views

13 contestants for Mr Ugly pageant

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 65 Views

Charumbira vows to resist plot to expel him from Zanu-PF

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 63 Views

Sonny Phiri appointed PDP-Biti acting deputy chairperson

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 47 Views

Reprieve for Mutare vendors

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 43 Views

Govt to tap into Aids levy to fight cancer scourge

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 39 Views

5-yr-old girl dies as fuel dealer's house catches fire

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 43 Views

MDC Alliance captures Zapu

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 61 Views

Questions in Tonga nearly disrupt Zimbabwe parliament

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 54 Views

FC Platinum dislodge Dembare

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 35 Views

Bogus Zimbabwean healers nabbed in Botswana goblin scam

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 61 Views

'Mutsvangwa has no say in Zanu-PF affairs'

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 50 Views

Mujuru to launch alliance

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 67 Views

Serial exam cheat caught red-handed

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 52 Views

Zec records low voter registration

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 34 Views

Shot taxi driver in court for 'stealing' client's $6,700

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 47 Views

40 year old man wanted in connection with attempted murder

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 25 Views

Policeman takes on VID in court

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 43 Views

'I am not an imbecile,' says Charamba

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 73 Views

Mujuru in $4.5 million scam

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 32 Views

Tsvangirai allies pleads with UK to lift sanctions

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 31 Views

Zimra beats revenue targets again

by Staff reporter | 19 October 2017 | 35 Views

Man acquitted on charges of insulting cops

by Stephen Jakes | 19 October 2017 | 31 Views

MRP leader case postponed again

by Stephen Jakes | 19 October 2017 | 21 Views