ZEC wins BVR kits tender challenge

ZEC wins BVR kits tender challenge
Published: 24 February 2018 (179 Views)
The Administrative Court has upheld a decision by the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (ZEC) to award a tender to a New York-based company, IPSIDY, to supply a biometric voter registration (BVR) de-duplication hardware and software.

This followed an appeal by a Chinese company, Laxton Group Limited, which in June last year won the tender to supply BVR kits ahead of this year's harmonised elections.

In essence, de-duplication equipment and software is used to eliminate redundant or repeated copies of data in a biometric system. Aggrieved by the decision by ZEC and State Procurement Board (SPB) to award IPSIDY, Laxton Group approached the Administrative Court to set aside the tender.

In his judgment handed down yesterday, Justice Herbert Mandeya upheld ZEC's decision that IPSIDY's bid was the most economically advantageous. It was noted that while Laxton Group's bid was $1,9 million, IPSIDY had submitted a $1,7 million bid.

"In evaluating Laxton Group's bid and that of IPSIDY, ZEC found that the appellant's bid costs more than the third respondent's. It also took into account the other most economic advantageous tender (MEAT) factors as discussed earlier," said Justice Mandeya.

Justice Mandeya noted that Laxton Group entered the tender knowing fully well that ZEC intended to procure the service at the lowest possible cost.

"But procuring entities go to tender to obtain the best services at the cheapest cost. It is, therefore, odd that the appellant did not query why ZEC had invited tenders in this case," he said.

"In a tender such as the present one, only one bidder would in the end win the tender. The other bidders would lose as what happened to the appellant in this case."

Justice Mandeya dismissed claims by Laxton Group that IPSIDY was insolvent, saying the issue was never raised with SPB, ZEC or a tribunal of first instance.
Related Stories:

"For that reason, the sixth ground of appeal is dismissed with costs," he said.

The court also noted that the allegation that IPSIDY had not been security vetted was being raised for the first time before the court, hence could not be considered by a court of appeal such as the Administrative Court.

"This court sat as a court of appeal in this case. In an appeal, the issues before the court are those raised by the appellant in its grounds of appeal," said Justice Mandeya.

"Appellant's grounds of appeal do not raise the issue of whether or not IPSIDY was security vetted. Therefore, that issue is not properly before this court in this appeal."

Commenting on the court judgment, ZEC deputy chairperson Mr Emmanuel Magade said they felt vindicated and called upon all parties to move forward.

"My disposition and views have always been that the appeal was completely devoid of merit and ill-conceived. The award process was done above board and the court has vindicated that position," he said.

- the herald

Tags: ZEC, Court, Win,
 0

You May Like These Videos

Comments

There are no comments.

Latest stories

MDC dismisses Party Spokesperson

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 274 Views

MDC Founding Member calls upcoming elections fair and reasonable

by Knowledge Moyo | 19 June 2018 | 210 Views

You are Zimbabwean because Zapu said so

by Ryton Dzimiri | 19 June 2018 | 159 Views

Wining Zanu PF candidate vows to stand as an Independent

by A Mhlongo | 19 June 2018 | 278 Views

Chamisa says Mnangagwa want to kill him

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 310 Views

Looking for Pythias Makonese, please get in touch

by Ignatius Mabasa | 19 June 2018 | 136 Views

Zimbabwean immigrant appointed new senator in Canada

by Agencies | 19 June 2018 | 216 Views

Mnangagwa's lies exposed

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 272 Views

WATCH: CCTV sells out POS machine suspected thieves

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 161 Views

Zimbabwean gangster jailed 24 years in UK

by Agencies | 19 June 2018 | 178 Views

Mnangagwa challenges ZCDC

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 166 Views

Why digital money makes sense

by Nick Mangwana | 19 June 2018 | 129 Views

RBZ told to 'delegate forex allocation to banks'

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 146 Views

Govt sets aside $150m for Command Housing

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 156 Views

Zamalek table Khama Billiat offer

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 178 Views

UK embassy exposes MDC Alliance

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 223 Views

Chamisa unfit to lead Zimbabwe says Mangoma

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 175 Views

Adoption of MDC-T by Dr Khupe was 'mischievous'

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 176 Views

Police ban dangerous weapons

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 133 Views

'Call me Zodwa Wabantwana'

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 205 Views

Chamisa can't withdraw Alliance candidates says Welshman Ncube

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 173 Views

Mnangagwa heads to Mashonaland Central

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 135 Views

No load shedding, says Zesa

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 110 Views

Year-on-year inflation remains constant at 2.71%

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 118 Views

Zec says polls can't be stopped

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 107 Views

Zec to unveil ballot printing company

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 120 Views

Woman kills, dumps newborn

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 125 Views

Chamisa swallows Dabengwa

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 209 Views

12 years jail for church burglar

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 103 Views

Pregnancy storm after teens' incest

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 130 Views

FreeZim wins t-shirts wrangle with ZRP

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 81 Views

'Mugabe was told of missing diamonds'

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 104 Views

Calls for Kasukuwere's arrest

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 91 Views

Mujuru speaks on national healing

by Staff reporter | 19 June 2018 | 66 Views