MDC poll demands outrageous, says Charamba

MDC poll demands outrageous, says Charamba
Published: 23 May 2018 (145 Views)
Demands by some opposition political parties that they should be involved in the printing of ballot papers to be used in this year's harmonised elections are outrageous as they are fully aware of the independence of constitutional bodies such as the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission, which they helped to create during the era of the Government of National Unity.

In recent weeks, MDC-T faction led by Mr Nelson Chamisa and its alliance partners went all over demanding to be involved in the ballot paper tendering process ostensibly as a way of testing the freeness and fairness of the polls.
Secretary for Information, Media and Broadcasting Services Mr George Charamba yesterday told The Herald that political parties advocating such an arrangement should first downgrade the constitutional commissions to ordinary statutory bodies by way of amending the constitution.

In any case, Mr Charamba said, the demands were devoid of merit as they were not backed by any law.
"They (opposition parties) must go back to the Zimbabwean people and say we have had enough of the independence of these constitutional bodies because we now want to participate in tenders," said Mr Charamba.

"But to try and suggest that their involvement in tendering process is the test of freeness and fairness of elections is quite preposterous and this Government will err on the side of defending the constitutional inviolability of these commissions. Besides, there is no law that accommodates these demands by the opposition.

"What the law provides for is not the tendering process for ballot material, rather it is the transparent management of the material once it's done and this takes many forms.

"Firstly, we have elections agents who are expected to keep an eagle eye on the electoral process from start to finish insisting probity at every stage. Secondly, there are processes of ensuring that all participating parties are satisfied that there is nothing stuffed in ballot boxes before polling, during polling, after polling and before counting. The cure cannot be by overrunning constitutional bodies in their processes. The cure is by ensuring that agents are fully and competently deployed.

"Also on the distribution of ballot papers, that information will be made known to all players and to say so is not guess mate Zec, it is simply to highlight certain standards of transparency."

Mr Charamba said it was awkward that the demand was coming especially from MDC-T which insisted on the setting up of the constitutional commissions during the GNU era.

He said it was important to remind MDC-T and other political parties that the constitutional commissions came into being at their insistence.

Said Mr Charamba: "I suppose some people have very short memories and because they have very short memories Government really wants to refresh their failing memories. Before GNU, we didn't have constitutional commissions in our executive system. The constitutional commissions came about on the insistence of then opposition which was now a partner in Government under the GNU arrangement.

"It was a very strident demand from both MDCs which as you know had very pronounced component of lawyers and the demand was that we must curve and station constitutional commissions around major rights that needs to be protected in the constitution. As a result, we had the various commissions most notably Zec, Zimbabwe Media Commission, Zimbabwe Anti-Corruption Commission, Human Rights Commission and a few more."

Mr Charamba continued: "The idea behind creating those constitutional commissions was to involve Parliament in their constitution so that their creation went beyond the interests and dictates of the Executive which is why the Standing Rules and Orders Committee of Parliament became a part appointing authority in respect of all commissions.

"The only difference was the degree of participation of the SROC in respect of each of these commissions. So, there was a deliberate attempt to insulate these commissions at the stage of constituting them by involving Parliament.

"Secondly, the other level of insulating these commissions against incumbents was to upgrade them from being statutory bodies to being constitutional bodies which meant if the Government of the day undermines their independence then that would amount to a breach of the constitution, in which case it will be actionable through due parliamentary process. A third way of ensuring and underpinning their independence was to require that they report to Parliament and not line ministries which really fortified their independence. The last way of fortifying their independence was to house them under the Ministry of Justice, away from line ministries for budgetary requirements.

"This was really an administrative decision. Now, if the intention was to underwrite the autonomy of constitutional bodies and this on the insistence of the then opposition which was now part of the GNU, where are these voices which are now demanding a reversal and compromise of that independent status coming from?

"If the intention is to re-think the subject, then you don't run ahead of the law by changing practices, you actually change the constitution and downgrade these commissions to become ordinary statutory bodies.

"That has not happened. But also it is very unfair for the opposition to expect this society to wax and whine on the basis of whim."

- the herald

Tags: Charamba, Pool, MDC,
 0

You May Like These Videos

Comments

There are no comments.

Latest stories

'I am used to these attempts,' says Mnangagwa

by AFP | 23 June 2018 | 296 Views

Mnangagwa's Zambian connection clarified

by Staff reporter | 23 June 2018 | 229 Views

Voters' roll row spills into Supreme Court

by Staff reporter | 23 June 2018 | 224 Views

Chidyausiku's widow sues JSC over terminal benefits

by Staff reporter | 23 June 2018 | 143 Views

'Zimbabwe elections, a delayed match'

by staff reporter | 23 June 2018 | 102 Views

Mnangagwa's ally sinks in debt

by Staff reporter | 23 June 2018 | 116 Views

WATCH: Where the Mnangagwa grenade came from

by Staff reporter | 23 June 2018 | 323 Views

Chiwenga's wife injured in grenade attack

by Ndou Paul | 23 June 2018 | 186 Views

Advice to MDC Allians:Know what to oppose and what to support

by Erick Matotoba | 23 June 2018 | 132 Views

BREAKING: Assassination attempt at Mnangagwa, Chiwenga in Bulawayo

by Staf reporter | 23 June 2018 | 190 Views

Mohadi, Muchinguri injured in Bulawayo bomb explosion

by Staff reporter | 23 June 2018 | 156 Views

Mujuru revives campaign rallies

by Staff reporter | 23 June 2018 | 104 Views

Chamisa victory not guaranteed, dynamics long changed

by newzimbabwe | 23 June 2018 | 129 Views

Mnangagwa campaign crews refuse to pay parking fees

by Staff reporter | 23 June 2018 | 110 Views

Mnangagwa is a different person, he has learned

by BBC | 23 June 2018 | 123 Views

Who wanted to kill Mnangagwa?

by Staff reporter | 23 June 2018 | 156 Views

Zimbabwe President survives bomb explosion

by BBC | 23 June 2018 | 103 Views

Mnangagwa is a shameless liar, says Jonathan Moyo

by Ndou Paul | 23 June 2018 | 116 Views

Second Lady 'hospitalised' after Bulawayo explosion

by Staff Reporter | 23 June 2018 | 144 Views

Mnangagwa visits injured victims after Bulawayo explosion

by Ndou Paul | 23 June 2018 | 78 Views

8 injured in Mnangagwa assassination attempt

by Staff reporter | 23 June 2018 | 76 Views

Khupe appraises candidates on campaign strategy

by Staff reporter | 23 June 2018 | 84 Views

One of Mnangagwa's VPs injured in Zim explosion

by AFP | 23 June 2018 | 69 Views

US condemns attempt on Mnangagwa's life

by Ndou Paul | 23 June 2018 | 79 Views

Chamisa should stop spreading 'fake news'

by Knowledge Moyo | 22 June 2018 | 366 Views

Presidential elections 2018 ballot specimen

by social media | 22 June 2018 | 390 Views

Government to float $150m housing bond

by Staff Reporter | 22 June 2018 | 233 Views

Chaos at ZEC meeting

by Staff reporter | 22 June 2018 | 322 Views

Mnangagwa stop lying there is no democracy in Zimbabwe

by Khulani David Ndhlovu | 22 June 2018 | 216 Views

'He wants my pregnant wife'

by Staff reporter | 22 June 2018 | 255 Views

Mutsvangwa calls for CSOs to let bygones be bygones

by Stephen Jakes | 22 June 2018 | 201 Views

Appointment of Zimbabwe judges opens can of worms

by Staff reporter | 22 June 2018 | 207 Views

Nkosana Moyo's unorthodox campaign plan unpacked

by Tinashe Kairiza | 22 June 2018 | 224 Views

Maphosa seeks safe haven in Zimbabwe

by Staff reporter | 22 June 2018 | 233 Views

Parties, media to witness ballot paper printing

by Staff reporter | 22 June 2018 | 182 Views