Moving away from the death penalty in Zimbabwe - has the time come for change?

Moving away from the death penalty in Zimbabwe - has the time come for change?
Published: 25 May 2018 (172 Views)
Zimbabwe has shown itself ready to embrace change in recent months but would that extend to abolition of the death penalty? The findings of a new public opinion survey suggest that this might be the case, opening up the debate on abolition of the death penalty.

The death penalty has been a contentious issue in Zimbabwe and in an effort to find out what the public think, we commissioned a leading criminologist, Dr Mai Sato to carry out a nationwide public opinion survey. The report was launched in Harare this week and the results presented (and captured in ">this short video) were surprising.

While a majority of Zimbabweans continue to support the death penalty, support was not particularly strong. Only 41% thought that Zimbabwe should 'definitely' keep the death penalty, with 20% feeling that it should 'probably' be kept - a combined total of no more than 61%. The report also identified that public opinion, whether it was in favour of retention or abolition, was, in general, not very informed or based on deep knowledge of the subject matter. Of those surveyed, 83% were not aware that Zimbabwe had not carried out any executions for over a decade.

When exploring the reasons behind support for the death penalty, it was striking that the “eye for an eye” argument did not hold much traction with the Zimbabwean public. Only 14% of retentionists supported the death penalty for retributive reasons, whereas similar studies conducted in Ghana, Trinidad and other countries have found this to be one of the most popular arguments in favour of the death penalty. Nor did the public think that the death penalty was an effective criminal justice policy, with 92% of Zimbabweans favouring policies other than “more executions” for reducing violent crime rates.

Most Zimbabweans accepted that there should be strict limits on capital punishment and were reluctant to impose the death penalty when presented with different case scenarios. Ultimately, 80% of those in favour of the death penalty would be willing to accept abolition if it became government policy.

Around the world, the death penalty is dying out. More than two-thirds of the world's nations have now abolished capital punishment in law or in practice. In 2017, executions were carried out in just 23 countries and there was a global decline in the number of people sentenced to death. In sub-Saharan Africa, the trend towards abolition is especially pronounced. Only two countries in the region carried out executions in 2017 - Somalia and South Sudan - and in recent years Guinea, Benin, Madagascar and the Republic of the Congo all abolished the death penalty. Of the countries that neighbour Zimbabwe, only Botswana has executed anybody in the last few years.

While Zimbabwe continues to retain the death penalty, there has been some positive progress towards abolition. An unofficial moratorium on executions is in place and in 2013 the new constitution gave full discretion to judges to consider whether the death penalty should be imposed in any given case. The last execution in Zimbabwe was carried out in 2005 - some 12 years ago.

What then is preventing Zimbabwe from joining the rest of the world's nations who have abolished the death penalty? In this context it is important to gauge public opinion. Frequently we are told that, whilst personally many key stakeholders are in favour of abolition, strong public support for the death penalty will not allow for change. But is the Zimbabwean public more averse to moving forward than other nations which have successfully abolished the death penalty?

The survey findings show that, while on the surface public support for capital punishment might appear strong, this is not the whole picture. Attitudes towards the death penalty tend to be highly qualified; where people sit on the issue will vary according to different assumptions, information and situations. When faced with the reality of typical case scenarios or the possibility of wrongful convictions, we often find that support for the death penalty wavers. Moreover, attitudes towards the death penalty are frequently misinformed and based on a limited understanding of the issues. Going beyond the simple question of support or opposition to capital punishment, this research sheds light on the nuanced and complex views of Zimbabweans towards the death penalty.

At the launch of the report in Harare, guests included not only the media but prominent parliamentarians and other key stakeholders. There appeared to be broad political agreement that abolition was desirable and achievable in the short term. The findings of the report served to underline the view that the public would accept such change.

Ultimately, abolition of the death penalty is a political decision requiring leadership. That is not to marginalise the importance of public views but rather to accept that public opinion should be sought to inform the debate on capital punishment, but not lead it.
This research, we believe, shows the Zimbabwean public is ready to accept change, but that this change must be explained. We hope that the findings will encourage us all to question assumptions made about public views and help to open the debate on the future of capital punishment in Zimbabwe.

-------------
Parvais Jabbar is Co-Executive Director of The Death Penalty Project, an international legal action charity based in London, UK. Val Ingham-Thorpe is Director of Zimbabwean NGO Veritas.

The report 12 Years Without an Execution: Is Zimbabwe Ready for Abolition? is published by The Death Penalty Project in partnership with Veritas. The study was undertaken by Dr Mai Sato, University of Reading, UK and was carried out in association with the University of Zimbabwe.

">Watch this short video on the findings of the study


- Parvais Jabbar and Val Ingham-Thorpe

 0

You May Like These Videos

Comments

There are no comments.

Latest stories

Emmerphoria marks Zimbabwe's policy shift

by Bruce Zvandasara | 20 September 2018 | 132 Views

Zimbabweans pin hopes on ED as he attends maiden UNGA Summit

by Nicole Hondo | 20 September 2018 | 110 Views

UNGA and Zim's international incorporation

by Anesu Pedzisayi | 20 September 2018 | 93 Views

Mnangagwa fortifies his political power

by Staff reporter | 20 September 2018 | 155 Views

Zimbabwe stops luxury car purchases for cholera fund

by BBC | 20 September 2018 | 115 Views

ZAPU position on implementation of Devolution of Power

by Zapu | 20 September 2018 | 92 Views

Mnangagwa makes maiden UNGA appearance

by Elijah Chihota | 20 September 2018 | 81 Views

PHOTO: Chiwenga's hand swollen

by Staff Reporter | 20 September 2018 | 216 Views

Mnangagwa arrives in New York

by Staff reporter | 20 September 2018 | 120 Views

Zimbabwe's impressive cabinet line-up under a severe parliamentary vaccuum

by Reginald Thabani Gola. | 19 September 2018 | 355 Views

Mnangagwa boycott the way to go, says MDC veterans

by Stephen Jakes | 19 September 2018 | 381 Views

Mudede hunts down staffer who revealed blacklist

by Staff reporter | 19 September 2018 | 460 Views

'Mnangagwa inherits Mugabe's anti-Gukurahundi traits'

by Staff reporter | 19 September 2018 | 250 Views

Mnangagwa snubbing the way to go

by Stephen Jakes | 19 September 2018 | 227 Views

Shame on you MDC MPs

by Munya Shumba | 19 September 2018 | 209 Views

Kariba on high Cholera alert

by John T Chirinda | 19 September 2018 | 153 Views

Parent involvement helps students to do well

by Agencies | 19 September 2018 | 132 Views

$6000 salary for MPs

by Staff Reporter | 19 September 2018 | 302 Views

Mnangagwa tours Glen View cholera centre

by Staff reporter | 19 September 2018 | 171 Views

Unresolved ethnicity conflict haunts Bulawayo

by Staff reporter | 19 September 2018 | 133 Views

Bulawayo's 'foreign' mayor remains unfazed

by Staff reporter | 19 September 2018 | 168 Views

Court defers ruling on Nduna's Chegutu West win

by Staff reporter | 19 September 2018 | 165 Views

Zoey SA bound

by Staff reporter | 19 September 2018 | 129 Views

Gukurahundi seeks to eclipse Intwasa

by Staff reporter | 19 September 2018 | 123 Views

Gukurahundi documentary deemed to be carrying inflammatory information

by Staff reporter | 19 September 2018 | 140 Views

Models at Prophet Magaya Prayer Mountain

by Staff reporter | 19 September 2018 | 167 Views

Chamisa turns down Parly invite

by Staff reporter | 19 September 2018 | 270 Views

Chamisa can only have an effective protest if all his MPs boycot Parliament

by Staff reporter | 19 September 2018 | 214 Views

Local govt has crossed difficult path since year 2000

by Stephen Jakes | 19 September 2018 | 127 Views

Ecocash and swipe are gradually being phased out

by Stephen Jakes | 19 September 2018 | 310 Views

So much hate in Zimbabwe, Mnangagwa needs to unite people - Mliswa

by Stephen Jakes | 19 September 2018 | 337 Views

Chamisa's MPs walk out on Mnangagwa

by Staff reporter | 19 September 2018 | 196 Views

Mnangagwa must consider Mthuli Ncube's proposals

by Editorial - newsday | 19 September 2018 | 221 Views

Mnangagwa rejects Mines Bill

by Staff reporter | 19 September 2018 | 180 Views