Coltart law firm ordered to pay a client +$12,000 for bungling a case

Coltart law firm ordered to pay a client +$12,000 for bungling a case
Published: 26 May 2018 (280 Views)
A law firm in which controversial MDC politician Mr David Coltart is a senior partner has been ordered to pay a client more than $12 000 after bungling a case. A former High Court judge, Justice Francis Bere, blasted Webb, Low and Barry Legal Practitioners for "lacking" professionalism.

Justice Bere, who is now Supreme Court judge, lashed out at Mr Coltart's law firm in his judgment following an application by Mr David Addenbrooke citing Messrs David Coltart, Josphat Tshuma and Norman James Pattison as defendants.

Mr Addenbrooke sought an order directing the defendants to compensate him after the sale of his property following a default judgment entered against him due to an act of negligence by Webb, Low and Barry Legal Practitioners.

Mr Addenbrooke, who was now being represented by Job Sibanda and Associates, lost property worth $10 300 after it was sold in execution as a result of the mess up by Mr Coltart's law firm.

In a landmark ruling, Justice Bere ordered the defendants to compensate Mr Addenbrooke $10 300 plus $2 507 being the legal fees he incurred in the lawsuit.

"In the result, the defendants be and hereby found liable jointly and severally, the one paying the others absolved in the following amounts: (1) The sum of $10 300 being the proved cost of the plaintiff's sold goods.
"(2) The sum of $2 507 being legal fees paid by the plaintiff to Messrs Hwalima-Moyo Legal Practitioners
"(3) Interest on the amounts granted from the date of summons to date of payment in full and costs of suit," ruled the judge.

The plaintiff's property which was auctioned included a Toyota Cressida and household property.
Mr Addenbrooke was in August 2011 involved in an accident in which one Ms Portia Mhere sustained injuries.
He was arrested, convicted of negligent driving and fined $400.

After Mr Addenbrooke's conviction and sentence, Ms Mhere through her lawyers Majoko and Majoko Legal Practitioners approached the High Court seeking $15 000 compensation for the injuries she sustained during the accident. In her lawsuit, she cited Mr Addenbrooke as the defendant.

Mr Addenbrooke in turn engaged Mr Coltart's law firm to defend the claim against him.
According to papers before the court, despite having been paid for the services, Webb, Low and Barry Legal Practitioners failed to properly handle the matter resulting in a default judgment against Mr Addenbrooke, which led to his property being attached.

Justice Bere condemned Mr Coltart and his partners for their conduct, saying they were liable for the "mess up" after assigning an inexperienced professional assistant to handle Mr Addenbrooke's case.

He warned law firms against using junior lawyers to represent clients without supervision.
"The plaintiff's criminal conviction bears no significance to the negligence of the defendants. The conduct of the defendants' professional assistant coupled with the conduct of an advocate they had engaged made them (defendants) vulnerable. They cannot escape liability. Perhaps this case is a clarion call to all law firms that it is a monumental risk for them to allow inexperienced young lawyers to represent clients with little supervision," he said.

"Young and inexperienced lawyers must be kept on a tight leash until such a time that they are able to go about on their own to represent clients on behalf of the law firm."

- zimpapers

Tags: Coltart, Lawyer, Firm,

You May Like These Videos


There are no comments.

Latest stories

Theresa May quits as UK prime minister

by Staff Reporter | 24 May 2019 | 68 Views

Dilemma of political emotions vs the Unity Accord of 1987

by D. Kamamba. | 24 May 2019 | 84 Views

Another Zimbabwean 'Beast' charms Sharks

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2019 | 79 Views

What Dabengwa said about Chiwenga and Perence Shiri

by Mandla Ndlovu | 24 May 2019 | 143 Views

Chiwenga, Zimbabwe army to boot out Mnangagwa through 'operation restore economy'

by Itai Mushekwe/Mary-Kate Kahari | 24 May 2019 | 139 Views

Dedication to Cde Dabengwa

by Iphithule Thembani KaMaphosa | 24 May 2019 | 80 Views

Devolution confusion - marginalised communities lose out

by MakhoPrecious Moyo | 24 May 2019 | 70 Views

'Hello Congress delegates! May I deeply kiss your conscience?'

by Nhlanhla Moses | 24 May 2019 | 117 Views

Political Reforms can UNITE Zimbabwe

by Darlington Nyambiya And Farai Maguwu | 24 May 2019 | 75 Views

Zanu-PF and the football connection

by AT Kadada | 24 May 2019 | 73 Views

A candle blown off from Chinehasha Village in Chiweshe

by Thomas Murisa | 24 May 2019 | 57 Views

Mthwakazi National Party pay tribute to Dr Dumiso Dabengwa!

by Mthwakazi National Party | 24 May 2019 | 42 Views

Zimbabwe EFF CIC's profile

by Zim EFF | 24 May 2019 | 93 Views

'Mining sector to reap from liberalised inter-bank rates'

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2019 | 80 Views

Another 'Beast' charms Sharks

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2019 | 74 Views

Mnangagwa's 'Open for business' mantra collapses

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2019 | 72 Views

Mugabe's spooks boss bashed to death: Post-mortem

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2019 | 84 Views

Canada miner in talks to buy Zimbabwe gold project

by Bloomberg | 24 May 2019 | 74 Views

Populist policies can only suffocate Zupco more

by Faith Zaba | 24 May 2019 | 77 Views

Monetary policy unlikely to resuscitate Zimbabwe economy

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2019 | 80 Views

'No immediate end to load-shedding'

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2019 | 82 Views

Air Zimbabwe legacy debts spook investors

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2019 | 94 Views

'Gukurahundi' stifling healing process

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2019 | 79 Views

Air Zimbabwe stashes US$5m in UK

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2019 | 84 Views

MDC congress: Redefining the people's agenda

by Tendai Biti | 24 May 2019 | 77 Views

Mnangagwa now more paranoic and desperate

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2019 | 90 Views

'ZBC losing $220 million annually'

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2019 | 80 Views

Chigwedere seeks son's incarceration

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2019 | 81 Views

Mnangagwa proving to be another Mugabe

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2019 | 56 Views

MDC member challenges Nduna's election

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2019 | 84 Views

MPs demand salary hike

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2019 | 104 Views

Chamisa rivals in disarray after MDC's court appeal

by Staff reporter | 24 May 2019 | 113 Views

Dabengwa: Struggle stalwart, war strategist, epitome of unity

by Sifelani Tsiko | 24 May 2019 | 64 Views