Constitutional Court to set number of precedents

Constitutional Court to set number of precedents
Published: 20 August 2018 (305 Views)
On Wednesday, the Constitutional Court starts hearing oral arguments and evidence in the electoral petition launched by one of the 23 Presidential candidates in the just-ended election.

This is the first such case the court will be setting a series of precedents that will be followed in future such cases. It is a new role for the court. Since its establishment five years ago, the Constitutional Court has heard a number of cases, but in these facts were clear and what the court had to decide was whether an action by a Government or private entity infringed a constitutional right, whether a piece of legislation was barred by the Constitution, or whether a particular process conformed to the Constitution.

In each of these cases, the court's final decision was unanimous, a 9-0 decision, coupled with a detailed legal judgment that fleshed out a particular section or sub-section of the Constitution. While no one knows the internal workings of the court, it is likely that each of these judgments went through several drafts before all nine judges were happy that the final version reflected the law in all its subtleties.

This time the court has a number of functions, having to settle questions of fact and questions of non-constitutional law besides looking at how all issues measure against the Constitution. Usually, this process takes place in a number of courts as a case moves up the line on appeal. But the Constitution, for a Presidential election, wants a final decision promptly and so places the whole process in the top court and does so with tight time limits.

The actual process in presenting a petition is laid out in a few sentences in the Constitution and not unnaturally the courts have had to explain exactly what this means and how general court rules operate. For example, Mr Nelson Chamisa, in his petition, cited all 22 of his fellow candidates and chair of the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission Justice Priscilla Chigumba as respondents or "defendants" in common parlance. This was why Chief Justice Luke Malaba in a meeting with candidates and lawyers after the deadline for any other petitions told them they could either do nothing or they could oppose the petition, giving their reasons.

From the original petition and the responses of Zanu-PF candidate President Emmerson Mnangagwa and the ZEC chairperson, the Constitutional Court is going to have to consider a wide range of issues. This is common in high end civil cases.

In a criminal case there are usually just two issues, precisely what crime, if any, was committed and whether the evidence shows beyond reasonable doubt that the person accused before the court committed that crime. Those launching or opposing civil actions frequently spray the court with a raft of arguments in the hope that one will strike home and win the day. In civil cases courts decide on the balance of probabilities and do not demand proof beyond reasonable doubt.

The arguments in the original petition and the two responses appear to fall into four main categories. First are the procedures to be followed in a petition with the two responses raising a number of matters. Regardless of its final decision, the Constitutional Court may well decide in its final judgment to lay down how it wants to see future petitions launched and opposed. The second set of arguments refer to programmes, actions and alleged inactions by the Government and its agents.

Generally, courts do not interfere in the Executive and Legislative branches unless there is clear illegality or unconstitutional matters. The final judgment on the petition will, explicitly or implicitly, guide future governments and parliaments more precisely where limits might lie.

The third batch of issues is over the administration of the election, basically whether ZEC performed its functions well or badly and if any deficiencies were serious. Since the commission is independent, the Constitutional Court is the only authority that can issue a definitive "end of term report" and may well use the final judgment to do so.

That will assist ZEC, along with the more serious of observer reports, to refine the process of future elections as it strives for perfection.

The final set of issues is in many ways the core of Mr Chamisa's petition, the allegation that a judge of the High Court, her fellow ZEC commissioners and the core headquarters ZEC staff, abetted by a swathe of the tens of thousands of civil servants drafted as temporary electoral officers, committed a premeditated and systematic fraud and did so unanimously.

Such a finding by the court will almost certainly lead to tribunals, police investigations and a spectacular set of criminal prosecutions.

On the other hand the court could decide, as the responses desire, that the same group ran the most honest and fair election in Zimbabwe's history.

The final judgment of the court and the detailed written judgment could come well after the time-urgent announcement of the decision, will not only create a needed precedent, but also set at least implicitly standards across a wide range of Zimbabwe's political and electoral life. It will also be examined in detail not only within Zimbabwe, but outside. Zimbabwe's nine top judges are equal to the task and we are confident that they will handle it and bear it well.

- the herald

 0

You May Like These Videos

Comments

There are no comments.

Latest stories

Knox Mutizwa wins August Goal of the Month award

by kickoff | 05 November 2018 | 956 Views

BREAKING: Gandawa on the run

by Staff reporter | 05 November 2018 | 1816 Views

Econet cannot distribute Kwese TV content to Zimbabwean viewers

by Staff reporter | 05 November 2018 | 1383 Views

Shoot-out robbers arrested

by Staff reporter | 05 November 2018 | 1419 Views

Mnangagwa ally warns economic saboteurs

by Staff reporter | 05 November 2018 | 1368 Views

Chamisa mobilises supporters for mass protests

by Staff reporter | 05 November 2018 | 1149 Views

LISTEN: Acie Lumumba speaks on how he got paid

by Staff Reporter | 05 November 2018 | 954 Views

Dzamara speak on Zanu-PF fights

by Mandla Ndlovu | 05 November 2018 | 917 Views

Minister Raj Modi Modi donates salary

by Mandla Ndlovu | 05 November 2018 | 782 Views

'I am a Trillionaire' Magaya says

by Mandla Ndlovu | 05 November 2018 | 1249 Views

Supermarkets to be blacklisted over cooking oil

by Mandla Ndlovu | 05 November 2018 | 774 Views

UK army to recruit from Commonwealth

by BBC | 05 November 2018 | 843 Views

Magaya opens up on arrest

by Mandla Ndlovu | 05 November 2018 | 846 Views

Kambarami is still 'Deputy Mayor'

by Mandla Ndlovu | 05 November 2018 | 694 Views

'Import ban must not go beyond December 21'

by Staff reporter | 05 November 2018 | 777 Views

Prophet Magaya puts fresh spin to arrest

by Staff reporter | 05 November 2018 | 799 Views

Chamisa's sign language interpreters get thumps up

by Staff reporter | 05 November 2018 | 789 Views

Mnangagwa to review Mthuli Ncube's 2% tax again

by Staff reporter | 05 November 2018 | 755 Views

Lumumba to be probed by ZAAC?

by Staff reporter | 05 November 2018 | 558 Views

Dzamara speak on ZANU PF fights

by Mandla Ndlovu | 05 November 2018 | 525 Views

Zimbabwe as a new gateway into Africa

by Minister of Finance Prof Mthuli Ncube | 05 November 2018 | 766 Views

Chiwenga's ex-wife looted millions

by Mandla Ndlovu | 05 November 2018 | 1155 Views

We are our own worst enemies

by Mapozho Saruchera | 05 November 2018 | 814 Views

Mnangagwa to deal with unexplained wealth and bank deposits

by Staff reporter | 05 November 2018 | 757 Views

WATCH: Chiwenga talks about Prophet Walter Magaya's lipstick

by Staff reporter | 05 November 2018 | 747 Views

Lumumba Saga takes new twist....War vets bay for Mutsvangwa's blood

by Mandla Ndlovu | 05 November 2018 | 816 Views

Chamisa demands Presidency

by Mandla Ndlovu | 05 November 2018 | 708 Views

Zimbabwean teachers miss out on New Zealand opportunity

by Staff Writer | 05 November 2018 | 651 Views

Zimbabwe to introduce e-provisional driver's exams

by Staff reporter | 05 November 2018 | 693 Views

Zimbabwe to supply water to South Africa

by Staff reporter | 05 November 2018 | 695 Views

Mnangagwa claims that 'good times will soon roll'

by Staff reporter | 05 November 2018 | 657 Views

Zimbabwe as a new gateway into Africa

by Hon. Prof Mthuli Ncube | 05 November 2018 | 760 Views

Chiyangwa appoint Karikoga Kaseke

by Staff reporter | 05 November 2018 | 659 Views

ZCTU demo: Ruling today

by Staff reporter | 05 November 2018 | 612 Views

Missing cop found dead

by Staff reporter | 05 November 2018 | 748 Views

Tagwirei marries long-time girlfriend

by Staff reporter | 05 November 2018 | 1167 Views

Zimbabwe relaxes maternity leave entitlement

by Staff reporter | 05 November 2018 | 712 Views

Zimbabwe to receive drugs, ambulances from India

by Staff reporter | 05 November 2018 | 633 Views