Has the military 'comported to the dictates and mores of constitutionalism'?

Has the military 'comported to the dictates and mores of constitutionalism'?
Published: 20 November 2017 (339 Views)
Last night, amongst other things, Robert Mugabe said in his remarkable address, and I quote, "the Command element (the military) remained respectful, and comported to the dictates and mores of constitutionalism". There is no doubt in my mind that Mugabe in that statement was trying to cleanse the military by stating that they had acted legally within the confines of the Constitution.

Whether that was done under duress or as part of a deal in which they will protect Mugabe and his family in future I do not know. However it is of course patently false that the military has acted within the "dictates of constitutionalism".

Firstly, section 213(2) of the Constitution states that Defence Forces may only be "deployed in Zimbabwe" with the authority of the President. That clearly has not happened and still is not happening. For all the ramblings in Mugabe's speech not once did he state that the military have been deployed under his instructions and it is clear to everyone that they are not acting under his instructions. So the original deployment was illegal and their continued deployment is illegal.

Secondly, section 50(3) of the Constitution states that any person who has been detained "who is not brought to court within 48 hours (of such detention) must be released immediately unless their detention has earlier been extended by a competent court". We know that at the very least Chombo, Kasukuwere and Jonathan Moyo were detained in the early hours of Wednesday morning. Aside from the fact that the military had no right to detain these civilians in the first place, they have still not been brought before a court or released over 5 days since they were first detained. One might ask Mugabe what aspect of this conduct comports "to the dictates and mores of constitutionalism"?

The only way the military can now respect constitutionalism is to return to their barracks, hand the criminal suspects they have in detention over to the police, and let Parliament do its job.

Now that Mugabe has refused to resign the impeachment process does not have to take a long time. Section 97 of the Constitution sets out a three stage process:
1. A simple majority of the total membership of Parliament must resolve that a question whether the President be removed from office be investigated;
2. On the passing of this resolution a joint committee of Parliament must be established comprising all parties represented in the House with the mandate of investigating the matter, which should allow Mugabe an opportunity to respond to the allegations;
3. If this committee recommends that the President be removed then a two thirds majority of the total membership of Parliament must vote to remove the President.

Section 97 does not state what time frame must be adopted. Indeed if Parliament chose to, it could move with the same unseemly haste as displayed at yesterday's ZANU PF Central Committee meeting and go through these procedures within a few days. There is nothing in the Constitution which bars such speed, even though it may be argued that Parliamentarians have not adequately applied their minds to the matter. The point is that if we are concerned about constitutionalism and respect for the rule of law there is a quick way of securing the end of Mugabe's rule, lawfully.

Once Mugabe has been impeached, then the provisions of section 14 of the 6th Schedule kick in to determine who becomes President. In terms of section 14(4) the moment Mugabe loses office, Vice President Mphoko becomes President until ZANU PF nominates a person in terms of section 14(5) to see out the remainder of Mugabe's original term of office. Of course ZANU PF yesterday expelled Mphoko from the party but that has no bearing on his role as Vice President because in terms of the Constitution he can only be removed from office if he is either fired by Mugabe or he himself is impeached in terms of section 97.

But even that should not pose a problem for ZANU PF because section 14 says that ZANU PF can nominate someone else "within ninety days" of Mugabe's impeachment - in other words whilst there is a maximum time limit, there is no minimum time frame. So ZANU PF could literally notify the Speaker of Parliament of their nominee within minutes of the final vote taken to remove Mugabe from office, leaving Vice President Mphoko with the dubious record of holding office as President for the shortest time in history.

Ironically if Mugabe had resigned last night in the presence of the Generals that would have smacked of duress and whoever took over would have been tainted with that illegality. In other words any new President emerging from that process would be hard pressed to appear legitimate in the eyes of the world, and such an ascendancy to power could in my view have been challenged in court. It is still a moot point whether even an impeachment process will be legal in the context of the military having effectively suspended the operation of the Constitution. But that is something that law professors will no doubt argue about for years to come.

So much for the law. The impeachment process I have outlined above will leave Mnangagwa as President of Zimbabwe, which he will then have to govern. As we all know the problems are immense. Aside from anything else the Constitution has been flagrantly disregarded in many respects since it became law in 2013. If he wants to secure broad support both domestically and internationally he will have to move rapidly to observe the existing Constitution fully in letter and spirit. But that is for another day.


- Senator David Coltart (on Facebook)

 0

You May Like These Videos

Comments

There are no comments.

Latest stories

Fixing Zimbabwe's 'fantasy economics'

by Martyn Davies and Hanns Spangenberg | 23 May 2018 | 54 Views

ZLHR challenges govt to implement the new constitution

by Stephen Jakes | 23 May 2018 | 55 Views

Blackdiamond releases new video and reveal new management

by Tidi Kwidini | 23 May 2018 | 47 Views

Obert Mpofu welcomes Kasukuwere

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 111 Views

Mugabe fails to appear before Mliswa

by AFP | 23 May 2018 | 98 Views

Zimbabwe govt needs to regain the trust of the people

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 46 Views

PHOTO: Shamu getting arrested photo goes viral

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 129 Views

Zimbabwe embarks on broadband connectivity upgrade

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 35 Views

Jonathan Moyo could be working for Mnangagwa, says Mawarire

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 65 Views

Mnangagwa paid a $2,000 bribe in Mozambique

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 93 Views

Councillors accused of vote-buying

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 65 Views

MDC poll demands outrageous, says Charamba

by Staff rpeorter | 23 May 2018 | 79 Views

BAZ to increase TV, Radio service coverage

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 59 Views

Zanu-PF warns party members against violence

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 63 Views

'Special anti-graft unit to reinforce Zacc operations'

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 59 Views

Khupe allies hits out at Chamisa's 'violent, vulgar' youths

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 80 Views

Confusion hits MDC-T primaries

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 61 Views

Mnangagwa heads back to Manicaland

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 75 Views

MDC Alliance's ballot paper demands slammed

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 59 Views

Police shoot two violent murder suspects

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 57 Views

Khupe, Chamisa parties to use same name, logo?

by Staff rpeorter | 23 May 2018 | 79 Views

Banking sector demands 60% pay rise

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 58 Views

Dembare players threaten strike

by Staff rpeorter | 23 May 2018 | 58 Views

Zec sends text messages to 3m registered voters

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 59 Views

Zimbabwen family in Johannesburg hostage drama

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 59 Views

Makamba trying to push Mlotshwa out of Telecel Zimbabwe

by Staff rpeorter | 23 May 2018 | 62 Views

MDC-T councillor arrested

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 79 Views

'Army won't let Chamisa rule Zimbabwe'

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 79 Views

Zapu urges people to physically inspect voters roll

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 27 Views

'Electorate misunderstood me,' says Tshinga Dube

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 33 Views

Chamisa, Khupe feud back to High Court

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 35 Views

Dlamini crowned Matebeleland North's Miss Tourism

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 46 Views

Mugabe to appear in parliament today

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 36 Views

Obert Mpofu to appear in court

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 41 Views

National Youth Service graduates defect to NPF

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 38 Views

Soldier gets 7 years for setting lover ablaze

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 32 Views

Zanu-PF youth plot Mnangagwa interface rally

by Staff reporter | 23 May 2018 | 36 Views