Zimbabwe Elections 2018: An unfolding novelty

Zimbabwe Elections 2018: An unfolding novelty
Published: 25 May 2018 (482 Views)
In this election analysis, highly-respected University of Zimbabwe's political science senior lecturer, Professor Eldred Masunungure, looks at the two main contenders- the ruling Zanu-PF and the opposition MDC Alliance and their chances of winning the impending harmonised elections. It is a no-holds barred analysis in which the learned professor argues that “youthfulness is not in itself a policy”.

Zimbabwe, post-February 2018, finds itself in a novel situation. The country's political landscape is without its two principal political fixtures: the long-ruling Czar of Zimbabwe, ex-President Robert Gabriel Mugabe of the equally long-ruling 55-year-old Zanu-PF; and the veteran opposition leader of the 20-year-old MDC-T party, [the late Morgan Tsvangirai].

The first was eased out of State House via military executed and mass-supported intervention code-named Operation Restore Legacy while the latter exited through the Hand of God. The two parties are now under new and younger political sheriffs, Emmerson Dambudzo Mnangagwa (popularly known as ED) leading Zanu-PF as well as the State and Nelson Chamisa now in charge of the MDC-T and its umbrella MDC Alliance.

Thus, a three-level 'new dispensation' ensued: in the country, in Zanu-PF and in the main opposition MDC-T. The 76-year-old ED and the youthful 40-year-old Chamisa will be locking horns in an epic, high-stakes electoral battle for supremacy and Zimbabweans as well as the world have no more than three months to know who the new political supremo in the country will be.

It is important to first acknowledge that the two leaders and their respective parties are not the only political gladiators on the political stage. In fact, the Zimbabwe political universe is inhabited by a bevy of more than 120 parties – many fittingly described as 'Micky-mouse' whose membership is smaller than that of many burial societies – only two really matter- the two mentioned above.

Anecdotal evidence suggests that in the upcoming harmonised elections, the other parties and their leaders are not likely to attract more than minuscule popular support.

Under the new political leadership, both Zanu-PF and the MDC-T have been reinvigorated, the latter evidently more than the former, at least going by the enthusiasm and passion exhibited at Chamisa's public rallies.

He has charmed many but also alienated not a significant few, especially within the old MDC-T, now bitterly contested between him and former deputy president Thokozani Khupe and awaits determination by the courts. Only the jealous and blind can deny the evident truth that he has energised his nearly moribund party and done so within a short space of time.  

Chamisa clearly has his strengths. Principally, it is his charismatic charm, energy, academic training and attendant intellect that seems to have edified his electoral attractiveness. But many see his greatest political asset as his youthfulness especially when arraigned against the gerontocratic cadres in the rival Zanu-PF. However, this asset may also be his liability if only because youthfulness is not policy. Exhibiting one's youthful persona without projecting the party's policy is a grave mistake; voters need to be convinced that you don't just seek power and its perquisites but that you are ready to govern and that you have the tools to govern and to do so with efficacy.

As I see it, a clear deficit area is what Plato, the ancient Greek political philosopher, called temperance, that is, self-restraint, a virtue that everyone needs, but especially so the public leadership.  It is likely that he will acquire this virtue with time.

ED has the clear advantage of maturity, experience, elderly charm – many, here and abroad, have fallen for his charm – and he exhibits both temperance and confidence. But his greatest asset is incumbency in the context of a symbiotic party-state relationship. In that context, the party can breastfeed on the state when it is thirsty and hungry. In short, there are innumerable strategic benefits that come with being at the helm of the state. On the face of it and perhaps because of the party-state synergies, Zanu-PF is organisationally fitter, financially more endowed, is ubiquitously present in all crevices of the state and society and has the depth and breadth of leadership to make the all-important difference between success and failure at the polls.

But then, he is burdened by the heavy baggage of history, especially his alleged participation in the gruesome Gukurahundi 'moment of madness' in the first decade of Zimbabwe's independence. He needs to come clean on this and an apology is probably a good starting point.

So, who will triumph in July/August?  This question would have been irrelevant earlier this year. Up to February, it was a near certainty who would triumph in Zimbabwe's sixth presidential and ninth parliamentary elections. ED would easily have effortlessly trounced Tsvangirai and his MDC-T (and MDC Alliance). Now, that certainty has been uncertain, courtesy of the 'new dispensation' in the opposition MDC-T/MDC Alliance. This is so in the context of another novelty; the manifestly freer and tranquil political and electoral environment that allows many, for the first time in two decades, to be able to freely express themselves and to participate in political activities virtually unhindered.

Notwithstanding what denialists may claim, Zimbabwe is 'threatening' to actually experience a fair and peaceful election with the further 'threat' that the contest may actually be free and credible.

In short, there is a new electoral trajectory. Previously, there was uncertainty of process and certainty of outcome. Now, going forward, there is considerable certainty of process and uncertainty of outcome, the very definition of free and fair elections in most established liberal democracies. My prognosis is that while the presidential and parliamentary elections will not be perfect, they will be free and fair enough to be acceptable both in and outside Zimbabwe.

Lastly, though the election looks like it will go to the wire, the greater likelihood, based on cold-blooded analysis, is that the experience, depth and state incumbency will trump youthfulness. But it will not be anywhere near a landslide victory for ED and his Zanu-PF. It is highly unlikely that Zanu-PF will seize a two-thirds majority, let alone a supermajority as it did (albeit controversially) in 2013.

Having said that, it is a distinct possibility – and desirable - that a post-election coalition government will be cobbled together, whoever wins. Were this to happen, it would be wise and good for Zimbabwe that the coalition membership goes beyond the partisan fortresses to harness the abundant competences that the country is richly endowed with. Will ED or Chamisa go solo? It's probable but unwise. Whatever the outcome, novel Zimbabwe will never be the same again.

- Southern Times


You May Like These Videos


There are no comments.

Latest stories

Callistus Ndlovu's body expected in Zimbabwe tomorrow

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 6 Views

Zimbabwe urgently needs own currency

by Edmore Ndudzo | 17 February 2019 | 7 Views

Tafataona Mahoso: A man of many hats

by Staff writer | 17 February 2019 | 65 Views

Anger at Mnangagwa over CEOs snub

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 64 Views

More bad news for Mnangagwa

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 89 Views

Mnangagwa tightens his security

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 68 Views

Zimbabwe maize harvest forecast at 900 000t

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 52 Views

Mnangagwa admits deploying military crackdown

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 148 Views

Mutambara pays tribute to 'literary giant' Mungoshi

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 111 Views

Chiwenga still in Indian hospital

by newzimbabwe | 17 February 2019 | 163 Views

Auxilia Mnangagwa's hand exposed in Zanu-PF youth league ructions

by newzimbabwe | 17 February 2019 | 155 Views

Zimbabwean facing UK deportation says fears being 'killed' at home

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 127 Views

Bushiri's private jet attached

by news24 | 17 February 2019 | 107 Views

24 bodies retrieved from flooded Zimbabwe gold mine

by AFP | 17 February 2019 | 107 Views

Mnangagwa launches crackdown on illegally settled farm occupiers

by newzimbabwe | 17 February 2019 | 105 Views

Mnangagwa claims that fuel and wheat shortages already fixed

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 122 Views

AFM drama continues

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 138 Views

Smart agriculture will boost economy

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 102 Views

Masowe woman in record breaking home deliveries

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 131 Views

Chamisa, Mnangagwa dialogue is not about power-sharing

by Nick Mangwana | 17 February 2019 | 121 Views

Zimbabwe unlikely to renew Bureau Veritas deal

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 97 Views

We remain committed to media liberalisation

by Hon. Monica Mutsvangwa | 17 February 2019 | 100 Views

City dwellers to get food relief

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 97 Views

Govt begins receiving applications for voluntary retirement

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 121 Views

MDC Alliance lie has no legs

by Staff writer | 17 February 2019 | 114 Views

Mnangagwa aware of Chamisa's renewed bid to relaunch violent protests

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 108 Views

Chamisa to bring everyone to Harare for a Mother of All Demonstrations

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 88 Views

NRZ slashes commuter train fares

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 97 Views

Selmor relives childhood in Tuku household

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 61 Views

Sex makes Zodwa Wabantu fat

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 119 Views

Bosso end pre-season training

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 95 Views

First private teachers' college opens doors

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 72 Views

'Mnangagwa invite a step in right direction'

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 80 Views

Zimta CEO earns around $10 000 before deductions?

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 75 Views

Haddon and Sly suspends workers

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 56 Views

Bulawayo water shedding worsens

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 60 Views

Bosso, Dembare face collapse

by Staff reporter | 17 February 2019 | 55 Views