Speaking ill of the dead? The uncertain legacy of Robert Mugabe

 Speaking ill of the dead? The uncertain legacy of Robert Mugabe
Published: 19 September 2019 (107 Views)
Robert Gabriel Mugabe, Zimbabwe's leader for 37 years, died on 6 September 2019 aged 95. Towards the end of Mugabe's rule, prophets predicted his imminent death in office while others circulated fake news of his death every new year, but he would always re-emerge from his Christmas holiday still appearing very healthy.

In one interview held to commemorate his birthday, he declared he would live past 100, stoking fears that the country would have to endure what appeared to be an indefinite period with him in power. However, as fate would have it, Mugabe died only two years after being deposed in a coup and five years short of a century. In contrast to Mugabe's ‘political death' in the 2017 coup, his actual death was not necessarily anticipated and it caught Zimbabweans occupied with the business of navigating through a very rough, dysfunctional economic terrain of military rule in a post-Mugabe Zimbabwe. The reactions to his death were surprisingly contentious, his legacy has become a hotly debated topic and the history of his time in power is being re-imagined in largely unexpected ways by different people.

Across social and print media, there are multiple narratives, informed by people's different experiences of Mugabe's rule. Some perspectives are attempting to rehabilitate what others think is a tainted legacy. Among those who benefited from land reform, there would inevitably be people who are grateful for Mugabe's land seizures and others who accessed political positions and economic gain from his patronage system. In contrast, the victims and survivors of political violence including the Gukurahundi massacres in which state security forces killed over 20,000 people in the Midlands and Matebeleland provinces, as well as farm seizures, economic collapse, political detention and extrajudicial murders, may feel a sense of denied justice.

Then there are in-between narratives that consider the good and bad aspects of this legacy. Among this group, some view the first part of Mugabe's rule as a golden age, often connecting it to the time his first wife Sally Mugabe (née Hefron) was still alive. They argue that it was his marriage to his second wife, Grace Mugabe (née Marufu) which triggered his long decline. Yet others suggest that it was in fact in the latter years, especially because of land reform, indigenisation and economic empowerment policies, ZANU-PF's youth empowerment drive, and Mugabe's confrontational stance against the imperial forces of the global north that rehabilitated the true hero status befitting his image as a national liberator. These perspectives suggest that his record in the 1980s was tainted by his reconciliatory approach towards the former white colonisers both at home and abroad, especially the relations with Britain and the United States.

By the 2000s, Mugabe had squandered what could have been an illustrious career by trying to retain power by any means necessary.

At another level, Mugabe receives a much warmer historical treatment in countries across the continent where he is regarded as an important historical figure of the liberation generation, even by those who acknowledge his mistakes. All of these accounts demonstrate the extent to which history, in the treatment of such leaders can be a murky, messy, sometimes subjective, disruptive and uneven terrain.

Amid the flood of discourses about who Mugabe was to different people, I was forced into questioning what I thought I knew about what Mugabe's rule represented. I looked up Mugabe's first interview after independence, and examined whether the fears and aspirations raised in that interview with a BBC reporter were realised and how he navigated them. Those promises of democracy and peaceful co-existence were suspended within a couple of years after independence because of Gukurahundi. The resettlement of landless Africans was initially delayed, only to be revisited in politically motivated chaotic land reform in the 2000s.

 Corruption, a patronage system, conflict, ethnic, racial and to some extent, class division, all culminated in a multi layered political and economic crisis that endures to date. By the 2000s, Mugabe had squandered what could have been an illustrious career by trying to retain power by any means necessary: witness his ‘my Zimbabwe' speech directed at Tony Blair which showed how he had personalised and the nation-building project under the guise of fighting against imperialist forces.

Retaining power by any means necessary derailed that nationalist project, with serious implications for Zimbabwean citizens and the region. Getting back on track would be a monumental task. Mugabe's means of power retention began with the Gukurahundi massacres and continued with the persecution of political opponents in the 2000s when Morgan Tsvangirai's Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) presented the most serious challenge to Mugabe's rule. Alongside unplanned land seizures, carried out without due process, and politically motivated economic collapse, these actions resulted in more than a quarter of the country's population leaving. Unemployment breached 90 percent while hyperinflation peaked at 89.7 sextillion percent. The weight of all these challenges produced massive dissent against Mugabe in the years leading up to the coup in November 2017.

Triggered by internal power struggles within ZANU-PF, a party that many had lost confidence in, the coup was greeted with euphoria. Even in the images on international media, Mugabe's removal from office was treated as a political death, with many expressing relief that they did not have to continue enduring his rule until he would eventually die in office. So, even the anticipation of his death in the years before the coup was replaced by his removal from office and greeted with even more enthusiasm. A few voices, including myself, were very cautious of this development given the legacies of coups in Africa. But during the coup, it suddenly no longer mattered whether ZANU-PF would continue in power, as long as Mugabe was removed. ZANU-PF attempted to regain political capital by claiming that Mugabe had been the problem all along. His successor, Emmerson Mnangagwa gave the impression that his removal would resolve the enduring political and economic crisis and even preached a gospel of re-engagement through declaring that ‘Zimbabwe is [now – own emphasis] open for business'. Even the semantics that it was not the president the coup organisers were after, but the criminals that surrounded him seemed not to matter. The incoming president was accepted by many, even celebrated for standing up to Mugabe. He even inspired renewed optimism and hope, although the MDC leader Nelson Chamisa also commanded a sizeable following.

These past two years of increasing repression and sustained collapse have triggered a narrative in popular and social media that ‘Mugabe was better'.

Yet I could not help but try to imagine whether the mood would have been the same had Mugabe died in 2017. Only two years into the post-coup dispensation, his demise seems to have taken on a very different character from what it might have been in 2017. At the time of the coup, Mugabe was viewed by those who celebrated it, in local and international media as the ultimate villain. But just two years later, for reasons I will now discuss, his image is undergoing some rehabilitation.

Two years into President Mnangagwa's rule, Zimbabwe is at the threshold of a second round of hyperinflation. Although Zimbabwe since 2008 has officially used only foreign currency, a policy aimed at halting the runaway inflation of the preceding years, the state has responded to a liquidity crisis by printing ‘bond notes' officially pegged to the US dollar but, in practice, of rapidly diminishing value. Some people have died from the state's militarised heavy handedness against protestors, for example just after the elections and during protests against petrol price hikes. Any kind of dissent is not tolerated and the crisis in Zimbabwe seems to be taking up a dimension similar to the years that most Zimbabweans would never want to re-live. Indeed, any fears of deepening economic collapse rekindles fears of ‘a return to 2008', almost as if history is working backwards. But these past two years of increasing repression and sustained collapse have triggered a narrative in popular and social media that ‘Mugabe was better', with some even saying that they jumped from the frying pan into the fire when they supported the coup.

So, the rehabilitation of Mugabe's legacy began even before his death, but with the news of his passing, these discourses have come full circle. As Zimbabwe's situation has taken a turn for the worse the euphoria that greeted the coup has been doused and in some cases overtaken by regret for supporting the coup and giving it legitimacy. But whatever the case is, it may be that some of these temporal circumstances are influencing the kinds of narratives that are being contested as people remember Robert Mugabe. Zimbabwe is again faced with having to endure another dictatorship, especially as the current president appears to have hinted that he may still be there even beyond the constitutionally stipulated term of office of 10 years. On the basis of this new constitution, Mnangagwa should be out of office, but many fear that his ‘2030 ne ndichipo [In 2030, I will still be here phrase]' might be an indication of yet another indefinite period under authoritarian rule.

Will Mugabe's legacy be rehabilitated and exonerated by history, and his image as the national hero of Zimbabwe and icon of liberation across the continent maintained?

The mixed feelings may in part be down to the Shona-language saying ‘wafawanaka', meaning that the dead are now exorcised of bad doings and therefore we can only speak of their good deeds. But mostly, the doubts stem from the country's current circumstances and it is uncertain what perspectives will endure. Will Mugabe's legacy be rehabilitated and exonerated by history, and his image as the national hero of Zimbabwe and icon of liberation across the continent maintained? Or will he be viewed as the demagogue who derailed the nation-building project of Zimbabwe and presided over displacement, emigration, murder and other ‘mistakes'?

Either way, I will take away my own realities as a Zimbabwean living in South Africa, where foreign nationals are uncertain of their future because of the host nation's own challenges with nation-building. I, like over 4 million others in the Zimbabwean diaspora across the world, fear the prospect of returning to a country whose prospects are, to say the least, bleak. However some may seek to rehabilitate Mugabe, all those thousands of deaths, the economic collapse, patronage and corruption cannot be dismissed as mere ‘mistakes'. They represent atrocities. So yes, while one cannot speak ill of the departed, it is very difficult to ignore these ‘mistakes' and the kinds of legacies they will produce for the unforeseeable future.

*About the author*

*Tinashe Nyamunda* is Senior Lecturer in History at Sol Plaatjie University in Kimberley, South Africa, and a former visiting fellow at the Centre for African Studies, University of Cambridge.

- Tinashe Nyamunda

 

You May Like These Videos

Comments

There are no comments.

Latest stories

PHOTOS: Job Sikhala becomes an instant internet joke

by Social media | 03 October 2019 | 256 Views

America says it is worried about Zimbabwe

by Mandla Ndlovu | 03 October 2019 | 312 Views

Madinda Ndlovu to be discharged tomorrow

by Staff reporter | 03 October 2019 | 192 Views

What are behavioral disorders and how can they be managed?

by Temba Munsaka | 03 October 2019 | 180 Views

Government speaks on Robert Mugabe's body parts

by Mandla Ndlovu | 03 October 2019 | 321 Views

Zacc recovers $100m property from looters

by Staff reporter | 03 October 2019 | 189 Views

WATCH: Mnangagwa apologises for destroying Zimbabwe satire

by Mandla Ndlovu | 03 October 2019 | 179 Views

Mphoko's application for release of passport dismissed

by Staff reporter | 03 October 2019 | 145 Views

Zanu-PF restructuring exercise begins

by Staff reporter | 03 October 2019 | 148 Views

Petrotrade declares $1.5 million dividend

by Staff reporter | 03 October 2019 | 93 Views

MSU, Zupco seal bus deal

by Staff reporter | 03 October 2019 | 168 Views

Mnangagwa to open ZMF conference

by Staff reporter | 03 October 2019 | 154 Views

High Court sets EcoCash hearing date

by Staff reporter | 03 October 2019 | 149 Views

Mphoko barred from leaving Zimbabwe

by ZimLive | 03 October 2019 | 150 Views

CIO agents monitor Jonathan Moyo in Kenya

by Mandla Ndlovu | 03 October 2019 | 375 Views

Acie Lumumba targets criminals around Mnangagwa

by Mandla Ndlovu | 03 October 2019 | 360 Views

$100 limit for cash-out transactions

by Staff reporter | 03 October 2019 | 260 Views

ANC starts anti-sanctions campaign

by Staff reporter | 03 October 2019 | 144 Views

ZESN calls for political parties regulation

by Staff reporter | 03 October 2019 | 126 Views

We've no forced labour evidence on Zimbabwe diamonds, says US Embassy

by Staff reporter | 03 October 2019 | 140 Views

Ex-ZPC board chairman freed on bail

by Staff reporter | 03 October 2019 | 135 Views

Cyber Bill seeks to safeguard citizens

by Staff reporter | 03 October 2019 | 110 Views

Cassava launches Vaya tractor services

by Staff reporter | 03 October 2019 | 148 Views

MDC Alliance boycott slammed

by Staff reporter | 03 October 2019 | 101 Views

10-man Bulawayo Chiefs stun Harare City

by Staff reporter | 03 October 2019 | 111 Views

Zimbabwe has a reputational problem, says US

by newzimbabwe | 03 October 2019 | 124 Views

MDC Alliance walk of shame

by Nduduzo Tshuma | 03 October 2019 | 191 Views

MDC councillors want suspension of Cowdray Park projects

by Staff reporter | 03 October 2019 | 113 Views

RBZ floats $300m additional TBs

by Staff reporter | 03 October 2019 | 106 Views

Teenagers rob soldier

by Staff reporter | 03 October 2019 | 116 Views

Duo rape corpse, get death sentence

by Staff reporter | 03 October 2019 | 124 Views

Mnangagwa to fly out for the zenith times

by Staff reporter | 03 October 2019 | 106 Views

Chamisa's MPs approach court to reverse 5 months allowance garnish

by newzimbabwe | 03 October 2019 | 84 Views

Zimra official forges Customs papers

by Staff reporter | 03 October 2019 | 70 Views

Zifa courts two nations for Warriors' friendlies

by Staff reporter | 03 October 2019 | 57 Views